'M' x 22 - "Orange"
by LN13

Comment:
mmm, juicy. definite improvement over the original. I think that your dof is fairly shallow though - it would have been nice to have all of the photo in sharper detail. good composition

Golden Brown Desk Bell 02.11.07
by EssAreDubya

Comment:
much more in focus and technically better than the original. I think you could have done more with your background - either used a color, or dodged it completely white. You may have also tried reducing the glare, though that's pretty hard to do.

"chessmen" by MorbidAngel ("Opposites" Challenge, May 2004 - IMAGE_ID=75572)
by photodude

Comment:
Definite improvement over the original. I wish your composition were different - it feels like the board is too far at the bottom with too much negative space at the top right. great job in controlling the glare and getting a nice clean background.

deja vu II
by kleski

Comment:
a deja vu of a deja vu, interesting : ) Did you look up the first original? anyway, this is a definite improvement over the brown ribbon one. it's hard to photograph jewelry (or other shiny things) though. It's hard to control the glare and to hide every little scratch or fingerprint. I would have liked if your focus on the dial were a little sharper though I give you props for attempting this shot - I couldn't pull it off

mildly annoyed kitty ready for a scratch your lens
by Melethia

Comment:
not sure about the grainy-ness or the type of border, but definitely an improvement over the original. I like your title and your composition - it was probably hard to get your kitty riled up like in the other photo, lol

The White House?? -- Transparency Challenge (Jun 24, 2002)
by treyvus

Comment:
I'm not so sure about the purple, but a neat interpretation of the original.

Rice by vignir_m (181325)
by hajeka

Comment:
yes, this looks much more like rice. It would have been cool to see a little bowl of rice or something like that; however, I understand that you probably didn't want to change too much from the original for fear of dnmc. I like the b&w - adds interest and takes the yuck part out of it

no fear ! "fear"
by grigrigirl

Comment:
hmm... this is a really cool photo, however - if I'm referring to the correct original photo, this is quite an interpretation/remake...

this one??? -->

Log by Raish
by jdannels

Comment:
Very beautiful photo - I like this take on the original photo. Even though the challenge criteria of the photo we're imitating doesn't apply to this challenge, it would be interesting to see what this looks like as a duotone. Great photo, I have no critiques

Calm Cool and Collected (Textures V redo)
by LadyK

Comment:
Nice take on the original. I think a less distracting background and more detail in the texture of the cat's fur would help. I like that you have the cat's face in your take - it adds more interest. Your colors match perfectly.