Apple
by arnit

Comment:
7Overall
9Challenge Met
7Color (tints, casts, bleeds)
7Exposure, Lighting (Shadows, reflections)
8Focus & Clarity
9Framing, Subject Placement, Background
8Visual Appeal, Subject matter
6Would I frame or poster-board this picture?

Good use of a spot light, but overall the picture is a bit too dark for my likes.

Staring Death in the Face
by Natasha

Comment:
8Overall
2Challenge Met
9Color (tints, casts, bleeds)
10Exposure, Lighting (Shadows, reflections)
10Focus & Clarity
9Framing, Subject Placement, Background
9Visual Appeal, Subject matter
9Would I frame or poster-board this picture?

A Day at the Beach
by falvey

Comment:
7Overall
10Challenge Met
8Color (tints, casts, bleeds)
8Exposure, Lighting (Shadows, reflections)
5Focus & Clarity
8Framing, Subject Placement, Background
8Visual Appeal, Subject matter
4Would I frame or poster-board this picture?

A Commentary on Small Talk
by greenem2

Comment:
Over all:
Challenge Met: 10
Color (casts, bleeds): 9
Exposure, Lighting (Shadows): 9
Focus: 9
Framing, Subject Placement, Background: 9
Visual Appeal: 8
Would I frame or poster-board this picture?: 6

This single picture received my only "9" (no 10s this time). The picture is a bit brighter than it needs to be.

Son's Trash or Treasure... You be the judge
by ambaker

Comment:
6Overall
9Challenge Met
9Color (tints, casts, bleeds)
5Exposure, Lighting (Shadows, reflections)
4Focus & Clarity
5Framing, Subject Placement, Background
6Visual Appeal, Subject matter
5Would I frame or poster-board this picture?

OK Papa?
by JEM

Comment:
Overall: 7
Challenge Met: 10
Color (tints, casts, bleeds): 7
Exposure, Lighting (Shadows): 7
Focus & Clarity: 5. -- picture seems a bit grainy and nothing is in sharp focus.
Framing, Subject Placement, Background: 9
Visual Appeal: 8
Would I frame or poster-board this picture? 7

House
by bojanzamurovic

Comment:
7Overall
10Challenge Met
6Color (tints, casts, bleeds)
7Exposure, Lighting (Shadows, reflections)
7Focus & Clarity
8Framing, Subject Placement, Background
8Visual Appeal, Subject matter
6Would I frame or poster-board this picture?

i've GOT to stop drinking coffee!!
by FranziskaLang

Comment:
6Overall
1Challenge Met
7Color (tints, casts, bleeds)
4Exposure, Lighting (Shadows, reflections)
8Focus & Clarity
8Framing, Subject Placement, Background
7Visual Appeal, Subject matter
7Would I frame or poster-board this picture?

Used, Abused, & Discarded
by CPattee

Comment:
7Overall
9Challenge Met
9Color (tints, casts, bleeds)
8Exposure, Lighting (Shadows, reflections)
8Focus & Clarity
8Framing, Subject Placement, Background
8Visual Appeal, Subject matter
5Would I frame or poster-board this picture?

Oh, and by the way, I know *exactly* where this picture was taken :-)

One Word
by Antithesis

Comment:
I am unsure what your message is here. If you are saying that the Bible is trash, I find that commentary very hostile. However, grading the picture as a submission to the "Trash, Garbage, Waste" category, here is my eval apart from my editorializing.

3Overall
0Challenge Met
3Color (tints, casts, bleeds)
3Exposure, Lighting (Shadows, reflections)
2Focus & Clarity
9Framing, Subject Placement, Background
4Visual Appeal, Subject matter, Originality
5Would I frame or poster-board this picture?