August in Zion
by sagestudio

Comment:
Striking image, the colour of the rock is amazing, as is the colour of the sky. If anything I'd say there is a bit too much sky. Also the foreground is very dark, I realise its in shadow and is suposed to be dark but because its not dark beyond recognition it distracts me from the main subject. Well done though, six from me.

November
by Koriyama

Comment:
Nicely framed, nothing wasted around the edges. Technically very well done, just the right shuffer speed I think. Good viewpoint, the stream leads you into the shot well. If anything the leaves look a little over sharpened. Well done a seven from me.

July
by Jean

Comment:
A very nice shot. Good sky, looks like a graduated filter? or similar effect? Nice lead in's from the seashore, the trees etc. However I find the people in the shot a distraction, I know its not your private beach, (is it? If it is then the best photo I've ever seen, can I come and take some,please), They are too far away to add anything to the shot. If they had been closer and walking into the shot that would have been about ideal. As it is the shot lacks some interest in the middle, without those figures the interest would have been the vast empty beach, in my opinion anyway. Well done though, a six from me.

American Bridges2004 - November
by sher

Comment:
Very nice sunset with some middle ground interest. I bit of a very nice silky feel to it. Couldn't go any higher because that's all there is, nothing wrong with that, don't get me wrong, I'd be very proud of this shot. Just needs something else in there in my opinion, like birds or a boat or something. It just seems a bitn two dimensional. Well done all the same and a six from me.

PS. I like the border as wel.

September
by davidbedard

Comment:
Nice shot but, the blue colour cast seems to detract from it for me. Also I think having the horizon right across the middle of the shot here doesn't work to well. I think more of the sea, (where there's some movement) and less of the bland sky would have worked better. For the record I think the border is great, well done a six from me.

November Storm
by mariomel

Comment:
Nice moody shot. A bit of colour in the distant sky, more would have been nice but unless you have a weather machine... The colours are very nice, not overdone I don't think, same for the sharpening, not too much. Very nice scene with a touch of atmosphere. With the tree, the plants and the rocks leading you out that way. Very well done, a six from me. Oh and I LOVE the border, sets it off very nicely.

November
by Jondor

Comment:
Very simple, very elegant. The duotone is excellent. The shadow is good, it gives it a 3D effect. The grain adds interest and gives atmosphere AND I think the border is wonderful, very nice touch. Well done a six from me.

... Bring MAY Flowers ...
by GeneralE

Comment:
Flower shots are not normally my thing but, I like the effect you have created and the angle at which it is shot. It adds interest to what would have been a rather dull shot. A six from me for being different and producing a worthwhile image, well done.

November
by Jacko

Comment:
I like trees and I like photo's of trees, its difficult to take a photo of trees and convey the feeling of the forest though. I think this shot comes very close. The colours are nice, not over saturated I don't think, slightly over sharpend perhaps? Nicely lit, good depth to the shot, well done a six from me.

Church Tower - November
by traser

Comment:
This was the very first image that came up when I started voting, I score them then come back to add comments. The colours are what make this shot for me and the light. The composition is rather strange, I assume there's something below the crop that you didn't what to include? Its strange how the red and gold trees in the background seen overlaid on the rest? Nice image, a six from me.