Rock vs Ice
by greslizzz

Comment:
Digital cameras have such a hard time with white. I perceive the strength here, but there just isn't any detail.

Biking is hard to learn.., and it hurts!
by olnos

Comment:
I gave this foto an 8, but your comment is out of line here. Photography is subjective, and on this site, majority rules. The subject of this picture is the girl, not the wheel. It is encouraged here that we give maximum consideration to the theme. That's the dificulty of this challange oriented site. Coming up with ideas twice a week that fit. My guess is that many people didn't think that it met the challange. You are exactly right that this is a wonderful shot, but your playing long odds going 113 to 1.

Papa's Umbrella
by milleniummike

Comment:
Rotate this subject and get rid of that distracting white rope and I'm with you on this one. Could be a litle darker to get rid of the wash out at the hub. Nice shot. 6

Ground Work
by crabappl3

Comment:
Very, very nice. Do I want more detail in your blacks? In this case yes. Lack of detail in the blacks of the upper right are tugging at my eye. Nice work. 7

Strong Flavas
by tezza73uk

Comment:
Well, this must be Italian, the chiles are red, and there is no tomatoe. Being from Mexico, I have to count you down, right? It's ok, I have an open mind! Your composition is a little to the left and those scraps of garlic skin on the canvas have got to go. But, object placement is very nice, and this is a rarest of occasions when I think that a border enhances any photo. Nice work. 8

Face of the Storm
by wilks

Comment:
Oh my God, that red might be digitally enhanced. Haven't you been reading the forums!!!!! I like it anyway..7

Power of nature
by brintam

Comment:
well, geez. silouettes, reflection, nice composition, interesting theme. guess you get an 8

Rusty Pipes
by Beerme425

Comment:
It's been a long time sinse I ran a pipe wrench, but isn't the rotation losining the joint. The oposite of strength? Light, composition, depth of field, all great. 8

BMW
by 19840624

Comment:
If you're going to print dark, you've got save detail. 5

When guns were wooden...
by kinks

Comment:
Blur the background, or tone it down and sharpen.