New Life, New Father, New Love
by Sonifo

Comment:
I saw this as a thumbnail and thought, what a beautiful photo for a father/child to have. I like the concept and I think it's great. Beautiful colors in the sky as well. 8 kdjohnson

growing in the wind
by FranziskaLang

Comment:
This really appeals to me....the movement...the color, the newly opening flower bud...very nice job-don't let anyone tell you differently.

Style
by Mieka

Comment:
Ok...whoever is in charge of window displays, I really like the idea of the blackboard behind them with the sentences written over and over....great back to school/college advertising. As for the photo itself...I like the composition....the light on the face to the left is a little harsh but what can you do with those? I like the photo..bottom line. 8 kdjohnson

A New Lily for a New Day
by jimmsp

Comment:
I like this...very sensual to me for some reason...great DOF and nice cropping with subject off center. I like. 9 KDJohnson

New Puppy!
by evilbunnee

Comment:
These are your "insults"???? I've seen worse. You need to know that while criticism may be hard to take, you should learn from it instead of be hurt by it.

Changing Out the Soap
by shortredneck

Comment:
I like this idea. I wish there was a little more light to it. Maybe just an adjustment of levels. I like it though. 7

A hand that's been through a lifetime
by fas-ligand

Comment:
ouch... great concept for this challenge. 8

wise eyes
by subtle

Comment:
This may be a case of shooting the photo and then cropping one part out and blowing it up. Or maybe you were just too close for your camera to focus well. I'm not sure what type of camera you're using so I'm not sure what to say.

Before His Time
by TomNTexas

Comment:
I think it was a good idea Tom...I don't get all the "disgusting" and "nasty" comments. His feet are wrinkled..."before his time" means old before his time...it's just a play on words/subject matter. I don't get folks...lol. I think it a different view of the challenge and you did a fine job. I can't believe that people actually leave comments like this....is this helpful? constructive? oh well...to each his own, huh? good luck in the future.

:O)

dividends
by magnetic9999

Comment:
I thought it was great mag...I gave you a 9 :)