All that remains
by Simonjw

Comment:
if i were standing where you were, i don't think i would have seen any merit in photographing such a mess; i like derelict stuff as much as the next arty farty fellow, but here all i would have seen is something without shape, coherence, sense of meaning or history or anything. but you obvoiusly saw something, and by jove, you were so right! it's wonderful, it really feels like the jetty was born into this environment. the use of a wide angle and presenting in portrait works really well, and does indeed give the posts a sense of shape and scale. and the more explorative viewer is rewarded with a stunning view and gorgeous sky, which compliments the jetty, rather than competes for attention with. the colours, predominantly those bluey greys, are super. 9.

Kyoto
by nfessel

Comment:
this is nice; very reminiscent of lost in translation. not sure about the b&W though, and also the tops of the stepping stones / trunks appear a bit overblown. personally, i think because of the film relation, the lack of a human element is more obvious than it would normally be, and consequently it feels as if something is missing... the crop is also a bit biased to one side, and it feels a tad unbalanced. likeable nonetheless. 7.

Lonely
by ShaneBlake

Comment:
so, this is the day you would be kicking yourself, what with the single tree challenge having just kicked off? tree position is also perfect, and good for the rule of thirds challenge... it's another lovely ir shot, though the tree is surprisingly yellow which kind of reduces the "wow, infrared rocks!" that normally hits me. it's almost like a giant cat peed on it. the big shadow is also a distrcation; i'm sitting wandering what cast such a large shadow (possibly the giant cat again...). the sky is really lovely, and the environment is beautiful. overall, very likeable, but i can't quite feel comfy about the yellows.. 7.

My Bliss
by Shecoya

Comment:
a beautiful, if conventional, landscape shot... it's actually odd in that given the mountainness environment, the moutains don't feel particularly awe inspiring. i think it lacks a sense of scale, and i'm not sure why. perhaps there is too much in the frame, or maybe it's the massive fluffy clouds that skerwers perspective?? dunno. 5.

Timid
by elsapo

Comment:
gorgeous picture. the greens are fantastic, and it's all just a splendid job really. the wee guy i really cute; i love that he has a beady eye on the camera, and his facial expression is so "well, what?". the colours and the way the focus works around him and the leaves are all stunning. and, right now, i really fancy a budweiser. 10.

Portal to Tomorrow
by sacker

Comment:
i love how clean and bright and modernistic the metal elements are on this. the deep blue is also visually appealing, though the level of grain conflicts with that of the surrounding element. it's a great abstract though; more so given tha i can't tell what it is. the centred composition is nice too. this really stands out from the other submissions, and i was drawn to it as soon as i noticed the thumb nail. quite striking - 8.

Bond girls
by LevT

Comment:
okay, this (as all things james bond) is a little bit silly. it's fun, very from russia with love for some reason, but a tad daft as well. it's also let down a bit by the fact the glasses on the right don't match the ones on the left in terms of opaqueness. a good laugh though - 7.

XI
by bragur

Comment:
love the hyper unreal tones of the colours. and the glass looking smoothness of the turquoise water is ttally gorgeous. to be honest, the graininess of the timber doesn't really fit in. or maybe it does. not sure now, but i think it's actually a good complimentary contrast. er. i wish the depth of field was greater; the slight softness of the numbers doesn't quite go and sticks out a bit. still, as a piece of visual abstract art, it's really effective and wall mountable. 9.

beauty and her beast
by PurpleFire

Comment:
i like this; it feels fun, loving, romantic and basically contently happy. and the emotions are infectious. the nice touches (the glasses, tattoo, and blowig hair) all add to the naturalness and candid feeling of the shot, and doesn't make it feel particularly staged. the background happens to be black, rather than it being a black background, if that makes sense, which i also like. the sepias work too. lovely - 9.

The Zinnia's face
by Trumpeteer4

Comment:
the face is uniformly blurry, which is a big issue with macros on flowers; the level of noise will also hurt your score. it feels like it was done on a mobile phone. an interesting species of flower though, and the colour reproduction is very nice, bold and rbight. but it needs better focus. 3.