Perfume: Makes' beady perfect
by birgir

Comment:
Very well done. This one is worthed to stay on a magazine cover. I love the soft focus and the warm lighting. I wish I knew what is that white environement. It looks like feathers and like veil. A little bit of both, maybe? 10 from me. I am sure will do good.

Awakened
by vtruan

Comment:
Greetings from The Critique Club

I am afraid this picture is going to give me troubles. Is hard to tell someone that you don't like something. You might hurt his feeling and this is not at all my intention. Specially when looking through the portfolio, all the rest is so incredible beautiful. I am sorry. I think it is the red next to the shades of pink that makes me look away. That what it is. It hurts the eyes. Otherwise, the photo has something to tell for itself. It looks as much as a flame as it looks like a bird. The red is a very intense color and can suggest lots of things starting from love and ending with rage. But it doesn't help the picture. The focus is good, I like the spark in the eye of the eagle. Somewhere, probably in PS the photo got a bit noisy. Other than that, no more complains. Everything else is good. I really hate that I have to post something like this. The good thing is that I can edit this at any time so if you have any complains, PM me and I'll look again at it.
Anyway... is just my opinion... others might think different.

Best regards, Elena

Lemon-fresh Scent
by HRoxas

Comment:
Very good concept, nicely meeting the challenge. Focus a bit too soft in my opinion. 8

Splash!
by arnit

Comment:
I don't need to look further. I know who is the winner. Congratulations! Great photo, by the way!

Sacred Resting Place
by BAMartin

Comment:
Greetings from The Critique Club

This photo is really good. Beautiful panorama. The light is soft. You have taken the picture at the good time. The black and white gives a beautiful atmosphere. The blue makes it surreal. The first plan pops out of the whole as the background scene makes the perfect frame for a subject.
The light and the mood are perfect for the scene. I think you have cropped it well, it gives the image extra depth, and it feels like one is drawn in to the picture. I love the siluetted trees. I also love the fence. It looks like it is dividing two worlds. I think you have succeded not to make this picture a cliché, partly by selecting B&W and adding the purple-blue tint. I do not see anything I would like to change. Maybe the final score.

Keep up the good work. Was an honor to critique your photo.
Best regards,
Elena

''Ice Fall'' by Shannon O'Cork
by kiwiness

Comment:
Wonderful indeed. I had no doubts about this one. I wonder why I didn't guessed it was you. But I don't dare to write to much. I am taking your precious time. You are not taking pictures but writting history.
With you on this site I don't even dare to write on forums anymore. I am afraid I will write stupid things and you might read them. Isn't somehow unfair to the world to be so talented and to have such a brilliant mind in the same time?

Wilderness: Worth Preserving!
by dsidwell

Comment:
Excellent picture and great idea for this challenge. 10

Drink, Drive, and Die!
by PDavis

Comment:
Good anti alchool propaganda.

CLICK TEN NOW!
by Paulk

Comment:
This is hillarious! And it works! 10

Shed Some LIght on the Subject, Read!
by sagestudio

Comment:
Very nice one. Clear picture and good idea. I love the lighting. 10