Beef Goulash
by cvt_

Comment:
Beautiful ... you were wise to keep the focus as far foward as possible.

Blueberry and Apple Muffins
by train

Comment:
Bingo.. a 10 even before the whole image was on the screen... lovely piece of work.

Two's Company, Three's A Crowd!
by brownt

Comment:
Oh my... hard to critisize, but I will. First, I gave you a 9... now-- I think that you needed to get the "white balance" to match the lighting. I think the yellowish tinge is probably avoidable though it would be work, I'm sure. The 'cream' could get away with being yellowish, but not the doillies. I do have a gamma matched monitor and I'll admit that my critique is on the edge. The photo is, otherwise, flawless.

Antacid Aftermath
by GeneralE

Comment:
Didn't follow guidelines unless you have the recipe. But you get a 5 just because it's pretty good image quality

Beef Stir Fry
by BigMo

Comment:
Stronger light, maybe ? Focus range is sure tight.. but I know that it's not easy to change that. Looks yummy ! Got my 8...

Sun rays
by pitsaman

Comment:
made me jealous. sometimes you are just driving along and it happens...
nice shot

Rocket Science
by alanfreed

Comment:
That's brilliant !! I know what it is !!! ... great idea ! I'm insanely jealous I didn't think of it.

Research on the color of the light
by rhipster

Comment:
Excellent.. got my 10

Chambers of Light-3
by Michaels

Comment:
OK, it's got the 10. You're professional, huh ?

using science to learn science
by hopper

Comment:
Normally I don't care for photos of a written page (in any competition) as I think it's just a lack of imagination. But your title made the difference becasue it "made" the glasses and book the actual study being done. (Hope this makes sense). And, obviously, you nailed it technically. I gave it a 9 only because I think that with experimenting with focal length you could have gotten a bit more of the text in focus, up front there. I think the hard focus area needed to extend to the '2 arctan' line as that area is still very close to the eyes natural focal area when viewing a new image. Out-of-focus past the leading edge of the glasses is fine. I agonized over this one for a while (I rarely write comments). Very good photo, very pro. I could see this as part of an ad in Scientific American or something. I'm sure others won't feel the same, but I like it.