Whoops ! Missed the first time - Apple challenge
by jessy_pesce

Comment:
beautiful shot. just the girl over the other subject is an improvement. I love the sharp focus on her eyes and the apple. the drops on the apple are also a nice touch. the only things are that you have some slight haloing and you could have benefitted from a different colored background. lighting is great

Hey jonathans, I found the butter.
by WalesP

Comment:
hmm... I guess an improvement over the original, but this photo is still very small in size and you can't hardly see the butter in the photo

Challenge: The Egg (March 2003)
by glad2badad

Comment:
beautiful take on the original. everything is in focus, the composition is great, I love the wood floor and dof... no nitpicks either

"Oops" by Shannon http://www.dpchallenge.com/image.php?IMAGE_ID=36236
by Lydia

Comment:
great take on the original. I love the pattern that the red, yellow and white made. seems to be in pretty good focus and the composition is great. my only nitpick is maybe having another small light shining from the topside of the photo would have lit up the yolk part better

Oranges ala Golnazzz
by bdenny

Comment:
your color seems to be a little on the dark side, but good saturation. this would have been better with a deeper dof on the oranges to bring out more texture and sharpness. maybe also use a smooth surface instead of the cutting board. I like the composition and balance

MMMMMMMMMMMMMM
by apashack

Comment:
your colors look great and you used the same composition as the original. not so sure I like the texture of the cutting board, especially where it is highlighted at the bottom by your light. this is a hard shot to do, but maybe a deeper dof would help on the fruit and not so much water pooled around the bottom. I would love to see a reshoot - this is very close

Breath's Entrance (catching barflies)
by raish

Comment:
hmm... I think you picked a very hard photo to redo - the subject matter is tough to make look good. however, I think it could be better if it were more in focus and possibly from a different angle. I'm also not too keen on the border.

"my essentials" by melodee
by k4ffy

Comment:
great remake - very clean, nice composition, no harsh reflections, soft shadows. the only thing that could make this photo better would be more interesting silverware - but that's hard to do : )

See: "the engineering marvels of general electric [aka where's the butter]"
by colorcarnival

Comment:
lol, what a great photo to reproduce. I would have liked to see everything left out of the photo except the butter and possibly the plate it's on. your focus also looks like it's on the can and bottle more than the butter. these are all detracting factors. I would be interested to see a reshoot of this with just the butter up close and filling almost the entire frame.

"I'm being followed by a Moonshadow" [Night Shot]
by NicNic101

Comment:
not sure if you're referring to this photo: but I'm going to assume yes.

as for this photo, I think that the glare (I'm not sure what it is) in the bottom left destracts from the photo - it's advanced editing - you could clone it out. I think you could have gotten a cleaner shot of the moon too, maybe by using a higher aperture, or faster shutter speed - or a tripod if you didn't use one. I like your composition and I would like to see this shot done again - it has real potential.