Barely Dressed (aka How I would turn image #412995 from Oxymoron Challenge)
by De Sousa

Comment:
well, very interesting photo, technically well done, good color, clean, nice lighting, I definitely like this better than the original

Color Blind II - Or should it be called Color Blind III?
by Alain

Comment:
well, that's a beautiful even green. no grain, can't tell about the focus... like that you added a border... however, I think you know how this is gonna go : ) good luck in the challenge

Fork Knife Spoon
by Monique64

Comment:
very nice, interesting silverware, great background, good colors, no harsh reflections, the only nitpick is I wonder what this would look like if the pieces were separated a bit - might not be better though, great job overall

Angry Kitty Ready for a Scratch Your Eyes
by Breeee123

Comment:
what a cool capture, must have been hard to keep the cat in the frame let alone anything else. maybe a faster shutter speed, more light and a deeper dof could help you get a sharper focus. I like the composition and your colors

Black is checkmated (or clear)
by boyd2000

Comment:
nice take on the original, it must have been hard to get enough lighting on the board without blowing out the pieces, I'm wondering if you could've tried lighting from below the board with a little bit of light from above. the only other nitpicky thing would be that the glass is dusty. I tried messing around with this in photoshop and it has real potential - I would try converting to b&w and using dodge/burn to even out the lighting, and selective highlighting on the squares to get rid of dust, darken black squares and lighten white squares. this is a very good start, good luck in the challenge

Kitty nose with appel
by quiet_observation

Comment:
nice remake, I like the b&w and good sharpness on the apple. I'm wondering if a slightly deeper dof could have gotten your kitty's nose a little more in focus. also, for the dpc crowd, maybe cropping way in so that you have a square with just the kitty's face and partial neck and half the top of the apple might have done better. great capture though, I love the look in those eyes

"Black is Checkmated" - Fill the Frame III
by elizadeb

Comment:
good remake of the original, looks like focus is good and the chess set is beautiful, the only thing is I'm wondering if maybe you took this from more of a ground level with the pieces, the board wouldn't be so confusing with the pieces - in this challenge, we didn't have to follow the rules of the original challenge

dead seagul on Ebay (622831)
by charliebaker

Comment:
hmm.. interesting take on the original. I think that considering your subject, the faded-out editing was a good choice. composition is good, maybe a little more space below the wing would help a little. I'm guessing though, that this isn't doing so well with the dpc crowd - I'm wondering if maybe you couldn't have tried other angles like from the ground view, or upclose maybe on the wing or with feathers blowing in the wind, but obviously lifeless on the ground... not sure, just some thoughts

Water Fun by Ashezz (Water challenge, Dec. 2003)
by IreneM

Comment:
very beautiful, great take on the original, clean, simple, sharp (talking about the focus), love the composition and colors. perfect

Kitty Nose With Appel <sic> 2.1409
by lynnesite

Comment:
technically a very nice photo, nice remake of the original, focus and composition are both great, the only thing is it needs a little something extra - maybe more color or something, I'm not sure, overall very well done