Sunday Night
by Makross

Comment:
Unusual composition, lacks DOF.

HOMEWORK !!! #@#§% homework...
by np22sa

Comment:
Works great as a B/W picture.

The Classics
by jaxter

Comment:
Poor focus.

Photo/Darkroom Tuesday Morning
by cwalmye

Comment:
Very poor focus. Should have croped the left side.

School Days' Bits & Bytes
by Alexuta

Comment:
Nice composition, but I find the shallow DOF distracting. IMO it would have been better to have had the centre in focus.

The Village School
by Riponlady

Comment:
In my opinion, rotating clockwise slightly and cropping the right side to the corner of the fence would have made a better composition.

Windmill at Dusk
by Nigel

Comment:

Originally posted by Strontious: a center composition? WHY??? placed off to the left, following the rule of thirds would have made this a MUCH better photograph

Why the centre composition?..... I tried it as an off center ROT crop, but somehow it just didn't work as a 640x640 crop. I wonder if it's because the focal point on the windmill is the centre of the 4 sails?

Any comments/ideas?

Several people commented that a full on front view would have worked better for the "square crop", but unfortunately the front view would have had a housing estate as the background.

Shannon
by Neuferland

Comment:
At first I thought this picture was out-of-focus, but then I noticed that it has been over compressed. Try increasing the quality setting when saving as a jpg. Your file is only 22,212 bytes, the maximum allowed is 153,600. When a file is over compressed a lot of the detail can be lost.

How's Your Diet Going?
by Cooz

Comment:
Nice idea, perhaps a coloured background would have given a better contrast against the Oreo?

Forbidden Love
by ericpi

Comment:
This is, imo, the best of the Coke/Pepsi pictures in this challenge