Watchful
by leaf

Comment:
Nothing in this photo really draws me in. Yes, there's a reflection, but its just of the building across the way. The people in the street don't really make an impact. More interesting would be to reflect a woman looking in and thus appearing to mirror the mannekin, or a shot of people walking away, adding a sense of isolation.

Kids in the Window
by nowlin

Comment:
A very cute shot, but the reflections don't really add to the picture. In fact, they look like something you would try to avoid in any situation, other than this challenge.

looking for a family
by dominic_m_99

Comment:
Cute puppy, but doesn't really meet the challenge.

Shiny tiles causes reflections
by akolagini

Comment:
An interesting perspective, but the subject is somewhat unappealing. I like the contrast between white and dark spaces, but the reflection doesn't really add much to the picture. Might have been a stronger shot with a vertical, rather than horizontal orientation.

Candle in the wind
by avermaa

Comment:
The composition is a classic one -- wine glasses and candles are a surefire romantic shot. The focus seems a bit soft across the entire picture. The colors a bit dark and muddy and the image has quite a bit of noise in it.

Empty Store Window
by RyanCowles

Comment:
I don't really like the composition in this one. The bridge is nice, but the traffic detracts from the shot and the bridge isn't well placed to higlight it. A more dramatic shot lined along the bridge a bit more would be better. The image behind the glass adds nothing to the shot -- I didn't know it was a store until I read the title.

a brick in the wall
by vonckje

Comment:
Not sure what I'm looking at here. The glare of the sky really overpowers the entire shot. A little less exposure might have retained more details of the building across the way and the sky (seems to be some nice cloud trails in there somewhere). The digital time and date in the lower left corner really detracts from the submitted photo.

Bride & Groom: The Night Before the Big Day
by tammiann

Comment:
The reflection doesn't really add much if anything to this picture, IMO. The expression on the bride and groom's faces could say quite a bit -- are they tired, uncertain about the future, or just drunk (bachelor/bachelorette party, perhaps)? A bit more emotion could really make this shot. The choice of background is unfortunate -- the wood paneling makes this looks too much like a snapshot.

myPod
by drydoc

Comment:
This doesn't do much for me. The reflection and background are of a nondescript room. The only person in the shot is reading a book. The whole image is static. I don't even get the impression that the guy is listening to music. The reflected image is a bit cluttered. Maybe having the guy dancing to music would have added a dynamic element that would have tied into the iPod subject better.

clear as mudd
by way2fast4u

Comment:
Ok, its water and its reflecting, but its muddy water, and its reflecting a parking lot. I just don't get what you are trying to do with this one.