Green Bird
by cfischl

Comment:
Nice shot, agree with tinky about the green, maybe up the sat JUST a bit? Background (IN MY OPINION) is a little distracting, with a tiny bit of noise on this monitor, maybe darken that a little, think that would help this a lot!!

Jacque

Early Morning Fishing
by philup

Comment:
From one who is wishing for a 5.5 now, LOL, nice photo, but to me the wow/pop factor is missing. Looks too real for most of the voters here (my opinion, only)!! The post processing did not leave this with the "electric blue" or deep golds that seem to be the only way to score well with a sunrise/sunset photo! I like it, wish the angle had put more lake, less trees in background, but that is a personal thing!

Jacque

Megan & Annabelle
by SandyP

Comment:
Love a good dog photo, and they do NOT come much better than this one!! Not sure of the age of the female human OR the dog, but both appear quite young, a GREAT feeling of innocent love is shown in this photo - at least to me, truly love this one Sandy, congrats!!

Jacque

Portable Mini-studio (Light Tent)
by Pug-H

Comment:
The left side of your "headgear" seems to blend into the background a little, at least on this monitor, so moving a bit more away from the wall may have helped, adding a bit more light on that side may have helped too.

Jacque

My little princess
by Cooz

Comment:
Nice photo, may of cropped off a bit more from the bottom, getting rid of some of those blown highlights, but.... my opinion! LOL

Jacque

A True Black Beauty
by olddj

Comment:
Sorry, I posted this in a forum, but not here, which was a bit silly!! LOL We took these in the late dusk time on Sunday night, just thought of it then, do NOT ask me why!! Anyway, took about fifty shots and used the best two we had, one for me and one for jorr!! Knew going in we should have reshot them, but kinda late by then and I needed an entry, so for these entries, we DO understand what we did incorrectly!

Jacque

A Mini Adventure
by JH

Comment:
I honestly think considering it IS a toy (obviously) your score is really not bad. As melethia commented, lots of people feel. Toys - (outside of specific challenges I E toys, playtime, children at play, etc), score low! Maybe people feel they are too easy to set up, we kmow that is not true, but....

Otherwise, slightly soft on focus of car - background colors are great to me, idea and execution were very good.

Hope this helps a little,

Jacque

Jumping with Strings Attached
by Pug-H

Comment:
Hi, David, ONLY thing I see (and noticed it instantly) is the muted/faded/dirty looking colors in the parachute itself, sky is great, focus may be a TAD soft, but that is natural for this type of shot and does not bother me much at all. The colors do, hope this helps at least a little!!

Jacque

Jump, Nippin, Jump
by jorr

Comment:
I did NOT give this a ten!! Guarantee that!! Though I love the photographer and the subject both (not with the same intensity, obviously), it is a harsh seeming photo with blurred edges, have not a clue as to how/why anyone could vote it a 1 or 2, but...

Jacque

My mental leap in realising my challenge idea!
by obsidian

Comment:
Eye candy is definitly an advantage, and this does NOT have that! LOL Sorry Carl, but firstly, the image does NOT convey any "Jump" to most voters, as someone once figured out most voters spend like 10 seconds to look at the picture TOPS, so you need a hook to start with!

I really think it is a creative idea, and that unto itself is a great thing - to me and a few others, anyway!! LOL

Will not start on the technical flaws, as with ours, they are well known!! LOL

Jacque