California Shade
by SamfordSpleenless

Comment:
This photo seems a bit off to me. Possibly a little soft on focus where it should be sharp? Perhaps a little different (non conventional) perspective would make this a stronger composition and stick out more to me. - 5 - JeB

American Independence Day
by justin_hewlett

Comment:
Great fireworks shot, and it will look even better outside of the challenge with some editing! A few things that I can't count against you for - some of the lens flare... great motion streams and great vibrant colors!!!! - 8 - JeB

Circle of Fun
by Ozzie

Comment:
Neat shot! I think this would be a little bit stronger if we couldn't see the cylinder go all the way through. Was something limiting how far over you could shoot? A smidgen to the left and this would be a great great shot! - 7 - JeB

London Eye
by tom_69

Comment:
I'm confused? I don't see how it meets the challenge... i've looked for visual circles as well as implied, or the thought of it and don't see it.What am I missing?? Please let me know so that I can reevaluate my score - JeB

Fishin' Hole
by glad2badad

Comment:
I love fishing! :) :) Great reflections on the water - they are there, but do not distract from the bobber... the intensity in the color of the bobber certainly leads me to it across the skies. I wish it was a little tighter focus though :( - 6 - good idea, but needs a little better execution. I think you are on the right path with the angle of the bobber being slightly off, it makes it seem more realistic, and less staged.

Chinese Aged Eggs
by kayt300994

Comment:
What exactly are chinesed aged eggs? I am definitely intrigued. I think this shot needs a bit more contrast thrown into it. Perhaps a little less busy - closed in on fewer objects and it would be a little stronger of a composition. - 6 -JeB

Put your nose to the grindstone........and satisfy the challenge.
by rjpat

Comment:
This shot needs more contrast to really move me. I bumped the contrast up in PS and it makes a completely different photo. Right now, the grays just run together for me... -5 now, -7 with contrast bumped up.... - JeB

road machine.
by art-inept

Comment:
This is a neat shot and I can see that the circle finishes, although i can't see it :) I hope that doesn't count too much against you with everyone else :( The black object just above the bmw logo distracts me though, it hurts the fluidness imo. Maybe a little lower perspective would have helped? - 6 - jeB

Fantasy Circles
by ninja

Comment:
This is a great shot in a tried and true succesful format on DPChallenge! You have good contrast - but I think maybe you could have used a bit more contrast in the sizes of the circles... - 7 - JeB

Summer Sparklers
by kaedemoon267

Comment:
I think this shot is just to small for me to fully appreciate :( Why was it submitted so small? - 4 - JeB