Past Reflections
by nikoner

Comment:
I know this is a small point, but it's a shame about the top right corner; the grass edge and the other vehicle just drag the eye away from the central subject. I think you should have cropped out the offending area or taken the car to a more suitable location. Right, moan over; apart from that, it's a great idea and I love the car and the fluffy dice just add the magic touchâ€Â¦ (7)

Hey, who's that handsome dude?
by notashamd

Comment:
10... Fantastic shot

The Old Meeting House
by snoopy

Comment:
This is a nice shot, but I think that the wide central column draws the eye away from the reflection; seems to affect the balance of the foreground / background images. Perhaps taking the picture from an angle such that the column wasn't visible would have given a slightly better result. (5)

Reflections on driving.
by lina

Comment:
This looks like a person with the head of a dog. It's great in that respect, and I can't fault the shot – it's actually quite amusingâ€Â¦ But, the mirror in the shot voids the challenge aspect; in terms of picture quality it's fineâ€Â¦ Sorry to be so negative (3)

Reflecting Flower
by arnit

Comment:
Well lit, superb composition, great colour, great shotâ€Â¦ I think the lighting is the icing on the cake with this oneâ€Â¦ (10)

Sunset
by Jacko

Comment:
Superbly doneâ€Â¦ (10)

Improvise
by Marsha

Comment:
Nice idea; B&W works really well. Also, I like the way you have handled the background. It blends really well and holds the balance in tact. The only real fault – and this is perhaps a little pedantic – is the area around the lid; it seems a little busy and that could draw the eye away from the central subjectâ€Â¦ Overall, great shotâ€Â¦ (8)

Party Favors
by hokie

Comment:
I think the white background doesn't work. It sucks the eye away from the subject area rather than pushing it into it. Perhaps a black, or even a dark red, would have set the shot better. Composition is fine, no problem there. Sorry to sound so negativeâ€Â¦ (5)

christafari
by johnny_justjohnny

Comment:
Interesting idea, but I don't think it works too well composition wise. Yes, it's a reflection; but I don't think there's enough of it. The water, which I assume is the prime subject, is – in my opinion – lost to all the distractions around the table that draw the eye away from the central subject. The lighting is a little dull and he focus is slightly soft. I think that cropping the image to only show the blue of the table, the bottom half of the picture, would have worked much better. Sorry to be so negativeâ€Â¦ (2)

Visions
by stephan

Comment:
OK, it looks like an illegal filter, however, I shall assume otherwise because it's still here. This is quite superb all said and done, and regardless of how it was achieved, it's still a first class artistic shot. There is a lot of emotion and even though the reflection in the eye itself is undefined, this shot still works – and very well. Good shooting (10)