Something Fishy
by crik

Comment:
Couldn't identify anything as the subject... The light patch near the center? the "sunny" patch in the upper right kept drawing my eye away. If that patch near the center was where you wanted me looking, it may have helped to employ the rule of thirds to some degree. I tryed viewing it strictly as an abstract but again my eye wandered aimlessly.

Hope that makes sense.

Where the Rubber Meets the Road
by GeneralE

Comment:
My eye just kind of wanders aimlessly around this shot. Not drawn anywhere. I can't really identify most of what's here (is that an ice cube?) so the title is completely lost on me.

Water, tea, and phones
by jnenvir

Comment:
Composition left me feeling crowded. The top of one head, the left arm of the woman on the right, the bottom of the glasses were all cut off. the space on the left edge seemed almost wasted and what I thought were your subjects were cramed into the space they had. Felt kind of unbalanced.

That make sense?

Fishing the Snake River in Colorado
by jimsapp

Comment:
8

Autumn's Totem Pole
by Lydia

Comment:
Definitely the most unique I've seen so far... Nice "out of the box" concept.

I think with this more abstract approach to the challenge, a heavier saturation may have been nice. Had you tried it?

unlike jobs, had the idea just not the skill!
by Giles

Comment:
Great concept. The execution isn't as bad as you think either :) The tilted horizon bothered me a bit.

"Who's going to take charge now?"
by vawendy

Comment:
I wish I could give a helpful comment here, but all I can say is Fantastic!

A pure 10

Apple Flagship Oct. 9
by sfalice

Comment:
Not sure if you meant to tilt the horizon. Not sure it works for me. Nice concept

"Forgotten"
by Joker1114

Comment:
This was the lowest scoring image that I gave a 10... IMO, you were robbed...

Best Buddies
by sekarmalathy

Comment:
Excellent tone range, composition... Lighting a tad harsh. Great composition! All in all an excellent shot!!! Grats!