Doriphobia
by Younger

Comment:
The idea isn't bad, but the execution leaves something to be desired. It looks like this was thrown together in a couple of minutes. More purposeful lighting would have really helped here.

End of The Trail
by pedahel7

Comment:
This feels more like a snapshot than a challenge entry. Shooting this from a lower angle and with the kid either standing tall in the foreground or running toward the far side of the fence would have improved the image.

Submission
by graphicfunk

Comment:
The pose and lighting are interesting, but I can't quite tell what's going on here.

Rest
by tjmueller

Comment:
The PoV is interesting, but the image lacks a clear focal point.

a colorful ending
by coolhar

Comment:
The sign is fairly well camouflaged in the tree. Since this was an advanced editing challenge masking off the sign and shifting the hue of the tree would have been allowed; doing so would have helped the sign to pop out.

Autumn impasse
by nico_blue

Comment:
The saturation seems a little overdone. I would have preferred to see more detail in the leaves and grass. The USM / sharpening artifacts are fairly obvious; if you sharpened before you resized then you may want to try resizing first.

Urban Cliff Edge
by RulerZigzag

Comment:
This is a nice image, but it's quite a stretch for the current challenge topic.

Dead End ... for a fox
by Falc

Comment:
The border between the sky and the rest of the image is too sharp - try feathering your edges when you mask the sky. Since this was an advanced editing challenge, burning the sky to give it more depth would have been allowed. The DoF seems to be centered on the dogs; I think that the image would have been stronger if the focal point was the figure on the horse.

End of the Road
by gurlwithapen

Comment:
I like this image, but I would prefer to have a clear focal point (a bent license plate, discarded shoe, tire tracks, etc.). Adding noise was a good idea, but it looks like you compressed it too much. Since you're still well under the 250K limit you would have been better off submitting a larger file with the noise intact.

Out to Pasture
by Jutilda

Comment:
The image is nice, but you used way too much USM when sharpening this image. The colors on the near side of the truck also look odd. Did you pull all of that detail out of a nearly black shadow? Burning the sky a bit would have reinforced the moody feel of this image.