Classroom- circa 1891- Our First Schoolhouse
by JeffryZ

Comment:
The intangible quality of light in this image is fantastic, and really makes the shot. I like your B&W treatment as well, the nicely muted contrast and the warm melancholy that it produces.

Red Jeans - 800 years out of fashion.
by Paul

Comment:
I'm guessing you're headed for a 4.x so I have to leave a comment - I think this is a great shot. I like the juxtaposition of old and new, the muted (but not completely desaturated!) colors in the back and the bright reds on the jeans. Your image is definitely about old and new at the same time, congrats on having the courage to draw attention to the new by both color and title even though the challenge is about the old!

1 2 7 5 A.D.
by TrollMan

Comment:
One of my favorites in this challenge, I really like the composition. Well balanced, leads the eye up and down around your subject and, above all, simple and powerful.

Benefit St.
by Pipe_Dream

Comment:
Yes, you have indeed captured the feel of this place, at least for me. The combination of beautiful colors in the buildings and the white in the snow work very well. The composition is strong as well, with a nice foreground element that adds interest and good leading lines into the background.

100 years-old cobble street
by carofo

Comment:
In my own shots I often struggle for this "heart of the street" intangible, and rarely achieve it. You have done it here. I guess you had to go really close to the asphalt to find the heart of the street though :) I have never been able to make this viewpoint work for me, but you have used beautifully here.

I like the B&W treatment as well, and the richness of the image. I am slightly doubtful about how well it meets the challenge, but still a 10 from me and my pick for yellow ribbon.

The old and the new
by Pixelstate

Comment:
Yes, your juxtaposition works wonders in this image. The composition, though very center-heavy, is great for your message as is leads the eye where all the people are converging, to the symbol of old, majesty and power. Well done.

I normally prefer a bit more natural toning (did you put in a touch of HDR there?) but I like how your tones add punch to an already powerful image. 10 from me.

Brooklyn Bridge
by supacohen

Comment:
I am jealous. I live in this city and not in a 100 years (forgive the pun) could have come up with this shot. Everything works perfectly: foreground, background, bird, sepia toning. Maybe the composition is a bit heavy on the right side, but that's just nitpicking.

And most importantly I love the overall feeling of the shot. 10 from me and my pick for yellow ribbon.

Ha Ha Tonka Castle Ruins
by M_Jayne

Comment:
I love the play of light and shadow in this image.

Rainforests: Millions of Years Old
by manic35

Comment:
Most nature shots I would consider shoehorned into this challenge, but I like that you went the other way and your pic actually exudes youth. Still, the subject is indeed millions of years old. I like the thought it provokes.

At Grandma's Kitchen
by h2

Comment:
This is a shot that will go unnoticed here, but would be right at home in a magazine, or on the wall of a nice restaurant somewhere. I like the grain / noise.