Queen of Diamonds
by m2iw

Comment:
I do not find anything that let me say this composition is based on the rule of thirds. OK the queen is entirely in one third, but my eyes are forced to follow the card border down to the "Q" damaging the effect of the rule. I think the problem is mainly that the photo is too complex, filled with interesting elements and lines.
In a few words: there is too much.

Deploy the skimmer..to the starboard third!
by dustinwilson

Comment:
It is a bit too confused. There are too many elements preventing the viewer to clearly identify the subject

Pears at the farm
by loseme

Comment:
Ther fruits are too dark

Cosmos
by tamatama

Comment:
I'm afraid there are not enough details on the flower.

Three in Thirds
by jlchaves

Comment:
Even if the flower on the right is well composed according to the third rule as it is the other one and the distance between their centers my immediate feeling is not a of third rule composition.
I think it is due to the fact that the central part of the shot is still so interesting with the petals overlap, making the shot to be perceived as a symmetric one.

Going Fishing
by sallyjo1

Comment:
Another fishing shot!
But this is really different! Two kids, two friends, maybe two brothers? So similar and so different. Fishing is not the pleasure here, going some where with a friend is! Fishing could be anything else; it is just a case, an accident. To me this shot is about friendship and this is why I like it.

I'm afraid for the unpleasant, all in focus background that makes beautiful an otherwise wonderful shot.

The Simple Pleasure of Each Other's Company
by diablo2097

Comment:
I like the concept, but I think it is not highlighted by the silhouettes.

Blackberries
by bogus

Comment:
It is a bit too complex and confused. My eyes move back and forth without finding where to rest.

Working with Wine
by oravsky123

Comment:
Sorry, I cannot find a focus point, here.

Raspberry sherbet
by David1411

Comment:
I think there is a too narrow dof here.