Nosey
by Squiffyeitherjag

Comment:
The angle you shoot this at is perfect. He's a beaut. My critique on it would be to have a slightly bigger DOF or focus on his eye. It looks like the camera was confused and focused right between his eye and nose. I think it would be perfect if that was done. These shots are hard to take, my parents cats always move.

Inspired by Seurat: Sunrise
by paganini

Comment:
very neat effect. I had to go on yahoo and look up Seurat, very interesting. I've seen his stuff before.

A Horse is a Horse
by erin_m02

Comment:
This is a very great photo of the horse. When the picture first loaded up I thought that the top part of the photo is a little wasted space. I think you should crop closer to the horse. The color on him is great.

Speeding in Leicester Square £20 fine
by Paulk

Comment:
very nice effect. I like this one a lot. The long exposure is right on and the blurring is great.

Sun Drenched
by Gracious

Comment:
I love how you've done the color on this. I'd like to learn how you did this.

Everybody, che-eee-se!
by kenbo

Comment:
jeremïsan wa resutoran de miruku to chïzu o tanomimashita. :)

Road to Fogginess
by kiwiness

Comment:
Great tones and lighting in this. I like how you've centered the road and it kind of just disappears.

Alle Menschen frei und gleich (New Year wish)
by Azrifel

Comment:
Hahahaha, I just got done reading your critique on my picture and came to this to critique some while I have time. This is random and I clicked on it and I got your shot.

~Critique Club Comment~

COMPOSITION- Composition is perfect on this. I like the use of thirds here and the cork is not centered. There is the same amount of space between the cork and the right of the shot and the bottle and the left of the shot. The subject is perfect for the theme of the challenge.

BACKGROUND- The aperature you used is perfect for the DOF in this shot. The choice to not go wide enough to totally blur out the writing on the bottle was good. The white was a good choice for a background. I thought of what it may look like in black but it would have been less of an impact on the black part of the bottle.

CAMERA WORK- Shutter speed and aperature are good. See comment above. I like that the bottle is still readable. The detail on the cork is very good.

DIGITAL PROCESSING- I don't see any hint of compression or artifacts. From the comments on my latest shot, you know the benifits of saving the largest file size you can for details.

MY OPINION- I had really liked this on during the voting of the challenge. It was in my top 3 or 4 in voting. I think technically it is almost perfect (the cork looks like it is tipping slightly) This is a great shot!

Let's go!
by dimitrii

Comment:
"Critique Club Comment"

COMPOSITION- The way you have placed everything is good. I like that you've filled the frame and don't have a whole lot of extra space in the shot. You could have cropped just a little less to get the whole bag in.

BACKGROUND- it is white

CAMERA WORK- Your exposure is great.

DIGITAL PROCESSING- you've compressed this good and your levels seem fine.

MY OPINION- I thought this photo was just average during the voting. I think it would have a little more impact if you would have the hand holding the passport and more in focus. Or what I think would be neat if you could have slowed down the shot and had the hand taking the passport out of the bag.

Ice
by lumbus

Comment:
This is great. Perfect shutter speed. I love waterfall photos.