Sharp
by srdanz

Comment:
Cropping needs work. Too much non-related imagery detracts from the subject. Color looks oversaturated

Metal Boat
by hossam

Comment:
Poor photo quality (grid in the sky) and looks washed out.

Tracks
by drz01

Comment:
Why a 3? Doesn't really seem like a terribly composed photo. You can clearly see trash on the ground, and the framing doesn't tell me what I'm supposed to look at. Too many distracting elements plus the framing make this shot look too much like a random snapshot.

Metal, that has caused most pain in the History of humanity !
by kbhatia1967

Comment:
I'm not sure what to make of this photo. Overall, it's difficult to believe. The lighting makes the ketchup very obviously ketchup and not blood. The lights on the right side of the waterfront throw the photo out of context with the crucifixion timeframe, and Golgotha was nowhere near water, as far as I'm aware. Maybe if you cropped/edited out the lights, switched to b&w, and gave it some dark shadows, it might be a more believable photo. I know this probably sounds overly critical, but I don't see the point in marking you with a low score but not saying why.

Mechanical magic
by palmfrodur

Comment:
Why a 3? It's just a bicycle part - really doesn't inspire any thought, no matter how well shot.

12-Guage Physics
by swallace

Comment:
OK, I think I figured out how you did this, and I'm assuming it involves a mirror and 90 degree counter-rotation? Wonderful shot! Really made me think. This is an example of what's great about dpchallenge, photographers inpiring other photographers.

Denied
by sher

Comment:
I love the harshness of the contrast. It works well with the grainy subject matter. Very striking, overall.

Convergence in steel
by arpita

Comment:
Absolutely stunning use of color and contrast. I love how the bridge disappears at the other end.

Cornered and Alone
by mesmeraj

Comment:
I didn't find this picture to be "over staged" at all, and certainly didn't find it to look like "stock photography". Would agree with some comments that more shadow would be nice, but the overall effect is great. I would have given it an 8.

seastack
by papa

Comment:
Absolutely awesome phot. I love... everything about it, but I especially like the tall grasses in the foreground. You've captured this wonderfully.