Friendship
by euskadi

Comment:
Beautiful tones and composition. 9.

Friends Through High Tides
by Sunniee

Comment:
Nice shot, the whites are a bit blown out and if they (the friends) were smiling I would have given it a ten. 9.

Not seeing the big picture
by octane202

Comment:
If only there was as much sharpness and contrast in the grass as there is in that cloud on the right I would have given it a 9, but there isn't so I gave it an 8. Nice shot.

photo in A minor
by saintaugust

Comment:
Having the dark subject (the fret board) shot against the dark background doesn't help this shot. The fingers look a little lacking in detail and a softer brighter light source would have helped with this.

To swim or not to swim
by pgatt

Comment:
This shot is confused by several elements. Firstly the lower left corner and the top left of the frame where the blurred foreground should have been cropped out. The over saturation of the colors makes the pool fence and the wooden area hard to recognise.

That darn pink!
by okiesisi

Comment:
Reasons I scored this a 3:
A lot of color noise giving it an overly grainy feel for a color shot.
The distracting black background against the white foreground is too much for the subject to make an impact.
The lines on the paper have almost no impact other than to make the shot look cluttered - am I looking at the lines or the marker lids?
The pink lid is almost out of shot.
You could have inceased the aperture to a higher number (like f22) to get a greater DOF, thus making all of the lids in focus.
What I liked: the vivid color - thats about it.

Writing Lines
by ty_roni

Comment:
What a magically clever shot, my choice for a ribbon.

Strung Out
by casualguy

Comment:
the best guitar shot of the challenge.

Meditation
by BobsterLobster

Comment:
would have scored it higher with a brown or warm tone - the green is too...green...8.

Green Lines...
by Wildpurple

Comment:
would have worked with the Point Of Focus closer to the camera...imho...5.