Underworld
by RKT

Comment:
Well it's a reflective surface alright. I can find a lot of interesting shadows and shapes in this abstract ... no idea what it is, but it kind of looks like a brown paper bag that is half submerged in water. The shot doesn't particularly appeal to me, and I'm going to not vote for it because I don't think I understand it properly. Just thought it would be best for you to get my comment and no vote rather than the other way around :-) Good luck in the challenge!

At the window
by Lorenza F

Comment:
Very nice image. Looks like he's waiting for something. It's kind of spooky in a cool kind of way.

2UCOrange
by apashack

Comment:
I like the composition, but think I would react better to the image if it the orange were in soft light rather than hard light. Also, I can't really figure out what the title means or the white stuff in front (if it's the reflection, it's confusing to me).

Blake House
by EstimatedEyes

Comment:
The reflection in the water is gorgeous. The parts other than the water, however, are too processed (tonemapping or shadow/highlight) for my taste, particularly the greens. There's a nice depth in the colors shown in the water that seems to have been removed from the rest of the image. The water part is really great though.

two of my favorite things
by laurie241

Comment:
I think I can see where you're going with this, but the light reflected off the rose petal in such a harsh way as to blow out part of it. The reflection part on the table is just right, however. I also feel that the white objects behind the rose are distracting. I like the picture orientation.

Reflecting the Sun
by maxxumg

Comment:
The clouds are beautiful here. They're the main part with interest ... very strong and good. The rest of it seems a bit ordinary, even if it is a nice spot.

Spoon
by banmorn

Comment:
Very nice colors! I'd love to see a sharper dof in the foreground particularly, but really like this ... bet it would be awesome with just the spoon alone too.

Lake Raven - Huntsville, Texas
by SandyP

Comment:
Oh Sandy, this is gorgeous. So calm, just perfect.

Pt-Judith 2
by wildiris

Comment:
This is very beautiful.

Safe Harbor
by edmeng

Comment:
That's impressive! I really like those buildings ... they look live knives. Nice color and composition.