eye see you
by SAScambos

Comment:
This will make Top10 I believe! ;) Like quite all of the image.

Good luck in the challenge!

What My Alter Ego Really Thinks About My Blackberry
by seethroughmylens

Comment:
Took me quite some time to see your "Alter Ego" :P
Technically: Wont be high puntuation cause it doesnt have that much editing overall, and there is a lot in this picture that could be done better... (Im sure you agree) ;)

Good Morning...
by Marika

Comment:
This photo has that tonality and DOF perfect! really like that. The model is very nice aswell, but I cant see the "Expert Editing" any place!

Good luck in the challenge!

Dissolving Woman
by Alex_Petrini

Comment:
hmm.. almost! Kind of to much smoke, and the attention goes to those light smoke areas.

Good luck in the challenge!

Manes
by bjoern

Comment:
Good looking model and horse! but square format photo in this one... hmmm, dont know. Then there is no "Extreme Editing" or editing at all, is it?


Good luck in the challenge

becoming
by BrennanOB

Comment:
This is kind of strange!, hehe... what does it represent? the coolest paper sheet, is the one under her right hand!..

good luck in the challenge!

Life's One Certainty
by geinafets

Comment:
This I do like pretty much!.. Could be in top3, if mine doesnt get a ribbon. so I prefer that you score at best a 4th position (so I can be in top3) :P

Good luck in the challenge!

Pigeon Woman
by ray_mefarso

Comment:
This is a nice b&w photo of a nice lady in the US! (or at least is how I see it)

Technically speaking, I would have a bit more lighting on her, and the framing a bit more open, to see what is all that on her feet (the birds, were a bit hard to recognize), her head (or hair) is out of the pic (over the black frame), and the lamp, has its base cut by the frame aswell.


Good luck in the challenge.

she
by skewsme

Comment:
Haha.. nice idea on this one! still I miss more sharpness and less grain.

I believe you could be in the Top10! (even not having a girl/woman!) ;)

Good luck in the challenge.

A Piece of Me
by RamblinR

Comment:
Cool idea!, amazing clarity on the model! (and I may say she looks fantastic aswell!) ;)

But!.. the Puzzle effect is a bit too fake, with too much depth shadow, and the lines dividing are quite disturbing.

If you just had uploaded the photo without the puzzling, it would get a 8-9 from me (even not having any "Expert Editing" visible, but I believe you did a great face treatment.

Good luck in the challenge!