Doll's House
by kevrobertson

Comment:
the lighting seems a bit harsh and the back of the chair that is out of focus detracts somewhat.

Bold and Beautiful
by Sonifo

Comment:
Looks like a cool special fireworks display. More DOF or just cropped closer to the center would help.

Sea shell semi fossil
by Gauti

Comment:
it would be hard to tell what this was without the title. the edge of the subject in the upper left is nice, but with that cropped out it would make a neat textured wallpaper for a computer screen. Well lit to emphasize the texture detail.

squash
by buzzmom

Comment:
greater DOF would benefit this picture Nice colors and background pattern.

From the rose bush
by jjbeguin

Comment:
nice creative touch on the color scheme. It loses a little bit though by losing the detail of the veins in the leaves

In the Clover
by Tallbloke

Comment:
Great shot. For me this has what alot of macro shots are missing, great DOF with the entire main subject in sharp focus. Great detail and bright complementary colors. the top and right could be cropped a little more and it would still be a great shot without centering the flower and bee too much.

".....In The Rough"
by tfarrell23

Comment:
from the guy that posted the other pic of a golf ball for this contest, I have to say I like yours better. Nice natural setting, I'm used to finding (er...looking for) my golf balls in the higher grasses. I like the very crips subject and background in this pic too. nice wide DOF with most of it in focus. nice pic.

Daisies
by spockling

Comment:
Relevance to challenge (2): 0.5-Because the circles in your picture are ellipses at this angle.
Color/Lighting/Exposure (2): 1-pink color cast most noticeable i nthe upper left.
Sharpness/Picture Quality (2): 1-daisies in upper left and lower right being a bit out of focus but so close to the main daisy are distracting.
Composition (2): 1
Creativity/Originality (2): 0.5

Slinky
by idnic

Comment:
Relevance to challenge (2): 0.5-there is only almost a circle in this picture.
Color/Lighting/Exposure (2): 1 - I like the glowing effect, a darker background might have made that stand out even more.
Sharpness/Picture Quality (2): 1-could use some sharpening
Composition (2): 1.5
Creativity/Originality (2): 2 - Interesting picture.

Crop Circle of Buttons
by kaelva

Comment:
Relevance to challenge (2): 2
Color/Lighting/Exposure (2): 1-nice black background, subject stands out well.
Sharpness/Picture Quality (2): 0.5-small
Composition (2): 0.5-contrived, but you get half a point for the patience to set this up.
Creativity/Originality (2): 1