Drilling Engineer.jpg
by olnos

Comment:
super capture...love it

Self
by Konador

Comment:
very good konador.. i like teh strong side lighting and the strong shadows it creates... and the inclusion of the hand is great i think...one of my favorites..we see the human face everyday by the hundreds.. i think it is one of the unique accomplishemtns to capture it in a form which creates immense interest. and this photo does that exactly..

sunrise surfer
by coolhar

Comment:
GREETINGS FROM "happy world of criticism club by mehmet"

this is a nice action photo. i like the diagonal tilt in the surfer's body. the waves are vilent, and gives hte picture a man vs nature look.. but there is some blur in the image, i wish you could have used a faster shutter speed..good work, keep shooting

"a better world through subjective criticism"

Eruption
by dsidwell

Comment:
GREETINGS FROM "happy world of criticism club by mehmet"

i should say man, your stuff is always nothing short of amazing.. and this one is no exception. wow!! i dont even know what to say. this is a great work of art, i mean the way you smudged and blured is just trully remarkable. you told it took a long time to create but i think it is one of the best creative photo editting i have seen. i have seen your other portfolio pictures and you are extremely good at dodging and burning. you can trully bring out the greatness in a photograph. one thing that bothers me slightly is that this photo seems slightly tilted to the right, it may be a optical illusion created by the clouds or the formation of the mountain. and also the clouds seem to be heavier on the right ride. and although this creates a nice asymetry i wonder how it would have looked if clouds were to be equally distributed in the sky.. i am looking forward to seeing your future projects.. such great work, keep it up

"a better world through subjective criticism"

Back of the bus
by DefyTime

Comment:
GREETINGS FROM "happy world of criticism club by mehmet"

i like this image lots, it has couple things going for it, first the pose and the positioning of the girl which i like very much and the expression on her face is a plus, but her hands in the side like that sems to indicate her being nervous perhaps, and that takes away some from the overall image. another thing is the optical illuison that takes place at the sindow. this is the primary point what makes the picture interesting i think ..and perhaps the model of the car that is coming from behind i mean what are the chances...lack of contrast is a issue though.. i would like to see this with higher contrast..great job.. keep it up

"a better world through subjective criticism"

Look out any window
by soccerdad

Comment:
GREETING FROM "happy world of criticism club by mehmet"

i trully love this picture. it seems like one of a kind..scenery is absolutely faboulus and even though i dont know the surrounding area this seems to be aperfect angle to capture such beauty. but the frame dont really feel like a window, it seems more like a frame created in post processing, so that is one downside that i see. other than that, i can hardly find anyhting else wrong with it, i didnthave a chance to vote on this challenge but i should have given it an 8 at least with confidence.. keep up the good work..

"a better world through subjective criticism"

Daydreamer
by heida

Comment:
GREETINGS FROM "happy world of criticism club by mehmet"

i really like this image. it sparks two diferent feelings in me, first one is that the woman on the bed is sleeping and the thoughts of peace and quiet comes to mind, and second is that the woman on bed is day dreaming,sort of like closing her eyes and reflecting on thoughts, which gives it a feeling of lonelines and sadness and bitterness. i love the tone and the contrast, i like high contrast in images in general. lighting is suberb and the model is breathtaking..positioning of the model and/or the cropping does a perfect job of enhancing this image. ..trully a great image.. bravo for a suberb capture heida...

"a better world through subjective criticism...

San Marco, Venice
by Kavey

Comment:
GREETINGS FROM "happy world of criticism club by mehmet"

this is a wonderfull image, i always want to do sneak style photography of unsuspecting individuals like this, after all when they know you are coming they loose the natural expression like they want to protect it like a government secret. i dont knwo the subject was posing or not but i think you achieved to capture a natural look and expression. i like the positioning of the old man and the pidgeon. image has a loneliness feel to it because of the fact that old man seems to be standing by himself and there seem to be crowd all around him, havent we all felt the same soemtimes.. this is a trully remarkable capture of human condition, it represents loneliness, wisdom and tranquility. even thou the man seems to be alone he also looks to be peascefull..and inclusion of the bird really gives it the final punch.. great work.. keep shooting..

"a better world through subjective criticism"

Painting the Corners
by toddhead

Comment:
GREETINGS FROM "happy world of criticism club by mehmet"

this is a great image. point of view and depth of field really makes this image trully a unique one. border in my opinion is intrusive and cuts into a big chunk of the ball, may be a more subtle border does a better job. i do not know how exactly you have done this shot, but i assume you have suspended the ball in front of the camera and took it like that, if that is the case, this technique can be used to create many interesting shots. so i would like to thank you for insporing me in a good direction.. i gave your image a 9

"a better world through subjective criticism"

walkway to harmony
by xburnerx

Comment:
this could have been a 9 image but it seems washed out and out of contrast.. very good otherwise (7)