Rover Net
by banmorn

Comment:
these arent reflections...nice image though
4 for beautiful photo not meeting challenge, would be a 6 or 7

take time to reflect
by mandyturner

Comment:
i think i already commented and voted on this, but doesnt look like the vote went thru properly so...i'll try n remember what my comment was, lol

really nice tones captured, good uncluttered composition but i'm not convinced about the centred comp. it did take me a little while initially to work out what i was looking at. i think it would be better with more negative space above, so the main subject sits along the bottom third line

Corporate
by Chiqui

Comment:
i like the slanting lines of windows, and the juxtaposition of the round building and square building

Reflections of Nature
by awrightlpc

Comment:
beautiful scene, reflections captureed well. composition works fine, and is aided (imo) by the foreground bushes. Lighting could be better

Lighthouse Reflections
by lisajames

Comment:
i want to see this w/out the slanting of the window frame, but i understand that would be hard w/out your reflection in the image. but because of the slant, the horizon is wonky. I like the reflection captured, i just wish the sky was a little more dramatic.

firetruck vanity
by Donald

Comment:
she seems to be pulling a face, which spoils the photo somewhat. lighting is quite flat, imho. composition is good, but because of the lighting colours are dull.

Reflections on Past Times
by mexico

Comment:
nice idea, but i'm not sure of the almost centred composition - not very dynamic, makes the photo a little stagnant. i would try cropping much lower at the top, so the riverboat becomes a more integral part of the image, and the composition becomes more interesting. Try this again on a sunnier day, because the lighting is very flat

Reflections of Kenaday
by Kivet

Comment:
i think the low DOF has worked effectively here, but the foreground (reeds) is a bit dull and not 100% sharp. However, the composition is spot on and fits the challenge fine.

scaffolding
by Yevgenythered

Comment:
i think the reflection is just the top right corner bit, in which case it doesn't really seem to enhance the photo at all, and is just there to give a link to the challenge. Having said that, the rest of the photo is really nice. i like theabstract shapes and patterns on the ground, and the B+w works really well to bring out the tones. the two diagonals brring the composition together effectively

Bridge to Nowhere
by greslizzz

Comment:
the tall format is interesting, but i personally would prefer it slightly squatter. the composition is good, drawing your eye to the bridge and mist behind, but i don't like the green hue, espesially round the trees. The foreground river is a good leading line, but could be cropped a little higher