Sunset at The Lake
by jeremycole

Comment by FranziskaLang:
A Comment From The Critique Club

Hi Jeremy,

I'm lucky because I get to write a comment on your beautiful sunset photo, and one at a lake to boot ... I love water :) Your photo makes me feel of relaxed warm summer weekend or vacation days where you just sit and enjoy. :)

You mentioned in your description that you followed the ROT and I think that was a good choice here. The swirling clouds in the sky are very pretty and needed to be shown off, and the sun is placed nicely, letting the eye wander around the sky and the lake and still find a resting spot. The reflection of the sun on the water also adds to the photo.

I am drawn a little to those objects on (above?) the water to the right, I think it must be shallow water with some old tree branches sticking out? Whatever it is, it's distracting, but nothing you could do about it without totally taking another photo. I would probably try and clone those out now that the challenge is over.

Technically, this is great, the sun is a little blown out, but that's what suns are so it's not a distraction and you have a nice tonal range throughout the photo, with nice soft colors. And that's I think where you lost out on a higher score. This is a beautiful shot, but not one that "shouts color", even though the color of the sky and its reflection on the lake are an integral part. For DPC, it pays to be obvious, and a lot of the top photos were in brighter, bolder colors. Boosting the saturation a bit (as was suggested in some of the comments) could have helped that a bit, but I suspect it wouldn't necessarily be the sunset anymore you drove so far to see.

You should get a print of this and hang it on your wall to remind you of that nice summer evening.

I'm looking forward to seeing many more good photos from you in the challenges :)

Please let me know if you have any questions or comments about this review.

Franziska.

Sunset at The Lake
by jeremycole

Comment by wewillexplore:
Nice shot. I don't like it for a color challenge, though. Nice horizon placement, though.

Sunset at The Lake
by jeremycole

Comment by kiwiness:
Beautiful! An excellent composition, and those clouds! Wow!

Sunset at The Lake
by jeremycole

Comment by rainbow:
I love the reflection of the sunlight on the sky and the composition generally is excellent.

Sunset at The Lake
by jeremycole

Comment by Fiver:
Nice array of clouds. very pleasing to look at. Similar to another picture.

Sunset at The Lake
by jeremycole

Comment by tomzinho:
for these types of shots if you lower the light (gamma) and boost the color (saturation) you can sometimes really bring out the light orange in the clouds. also, you might have cropped out much of the sky above and made it more of a panoramic shot; that would have worked well.

Sunset at The Lake
by jeremycole

Comment by justine:
Award winning sky....wow.

Sunset at The Lake
by jeremycole

Comment by kandyj:
One of the few sky shots I have seen without grain. Good job.

Nalle, Upside-Down
by jeremycole

Comment by thatguy:
Good picture, the color is nice and clear. Good job.

Nalle, Upside-Down
by jeremycole

Comment by PaulMdx:
Composition: Background bottom-left seems to confuse the pic a little.
Technical: Excellent focus and colour.
Meets challenge: Yes
Overall impression: Good subject and shot, background/composition lets it down a little. 6