DPChallenge: A Digital Photography Contest You are not logged in. (log in or register
 

DPChallenge Forums >> Hardware and Software >> tripod : slik sprint, bogen/manfrotto, or velbon?
Pages:  
Showing posts 1 - 3 of 3, (reverse)
AuthorThread
04/29/2004 04:05:42 AM · #1
thanks to the feedback i received, i've definitely narrowed down the options for what will be my first tripod, based on my needs and my budget. what i'm looking at now are the slik sprint pro, the velbon maxi 343e, and the bogen/manfrotto 714/718 b/shb. now i've got some more specific questions.

-heads. with the bogen/manfrotto: the big difference between the 714 and the 718 seems to be the head: ball head or quick release 3-way pan/tilt head. i know the quick release is preferable, but i have no idea if the hassle of having to adjust each axis independently (as i understand the 3-way heads to work) would outweigh the advantages of the QR. we also have a video camera; i'd imagine that needs the pan/tilt head so that it can be locked and pan smoothly.

-height. i'm 5'1, my husband is 5'7. would we be better with the more compact model which is easier to carry and has a max height of 4' or with one of the others which max at about 5'5"?

-uneven ground. generally, i also want to be sure that whatever i get is going to be functional in many situations, whether that's rocks or stairs or a hillside or my living room. i know the slik is good for that, but i'm not sure about the bogen/manfrotto. the velbon doesn't have independent leg spread, so it seems like that might be a problem as well.

-the slik and the velbon have removable heads and spikes on the feet, but the bogen/manfrotto doesn't. i'm not sure how important either of these are.

i know a lot of this is probably personal preference, but since i've never used any tripod other than the bendy-legged tabletop one that came with my camera, and since i haven't been able to find an easily accessible camera store around here, i'd really welcome everyone's opinions on the options i've narrowed it down to.

thanks again. :)

(i posted this as a response in the previous thread initially, but after a couple of days and no responses, i thought i'd try a new thread with a title more specific to the new questions. i hope that's not crossing any forums etiquitte.)
04/29/2004 04:30:11 AM · #2
I too recall seeing the on-line info that mentioned the Velbon Maxi 343E didn't have independent leg spread, but it isn't true! Each leg on mine is fully independent and is in no way connected to the others. There is a single hinge on each leg at the top that allows each leg to move in and out on its own. It doesn't have any way of locking the legs at a given angle. I don't know what other definition of independent leg spread they might be referring to! I have had no problems using it on uneven ground. I have also never found a situation where I needed the spiked feet.

My personal preference is for a ball head with NO quick release. The ball heads are smaller and quicker to use and you don't have a long handle to get in the way. I don't like the quick release because it adds an annoying plate to your camera body. I often carry around a digital camera, an analog SLR and a spotting scope. I never had enough QR plates for all of them and changing them was a pain. Plus, the spotting scope wouldn't fit in its case with the QR plate attached. I am much happier with the non QR tripod. It only takes a second or two longer to screw the camera on than to attach the quick release.

I also recommend getting a tripod that you don't have to stoop down to use if you can afford the space/weight. (Especially if you spend a lot of time setting up a shot like I usually do).
04/29/2004 09:07:18 AM · #3
As I mentioned in an earlier thread I have a 714b. Fully extended I would need to stand on a box to use it (am 5' 10"). Its also light enough to be used a monopod for tight corners. The ball head on this is easy to use and can be set to allow movement of the camera by the photog with enough tension to hold the cam in the position required or locked off. The head will fold down into the legs making it even shorter when packed.

As for quick release? I went out a picked up a Cullmann q/r plate for £14 - best of both worlds :)

edited for thai poes

Message edited by author 2004-04-29 13:09:02.
Pages:  
Current Server Time: 04/08/2025 07:24:46 AM

Please log in or register to post to the forums.


Home - Challenges - Community - League - Photos - Cameras - Lenses - Learn - Help - Terms of Use - Privacy - Top ^
DPChallenge, and website content and design, Copyright © 2001-2025 Challenging Technologies, LLC.
All digital photo copyrights belong to the photographers and may not be used without permission.
Current Server Time: 04/08/2025 07:24:46 AM EDT.