They Are Sweet Onions.... Really, Trust Me !!!!
by Drake

Comment:
You are a very sick person, and I like that.

This is... just... absolutely wrong on so many levels, but very funny. I do wish the flatware was more obvious against the background -- or that may just be lighting issues -- as you really want to call some attention to it given the joke. And while I know the mantra is "centered is bad", in this case, the off-centered-ness does not strike me as the best choice.

Very, very wrong. In that good way.

Stink Bomb
by Chez

Comment:
This is disturbing. But, er. On-topic.

Onions
by katlyn

Comment:
Really, uncut onions don't have that much of a scent.

I'm going to assume the apparent blur is deliberate, a soft focus sort of thing, seeing as how challenge overlapped this one and all. It's sort of interesting, although I suspect I would find it more so if the onions were on a somewhat more kitcheny or cuisine-related background; I don't normally find onions on velvet. A basket, maybe (possibly atop the current backdrop), or even if the onions had been strung together as they sometimse are... as is, it's sort of unsatisfyingly overly arty.

Hot Candlewax
by hughletheren

Comment:
I like your smoke wisp and the candle choice vs the black background, but if you were going for 'melted wax' there probably should have been a good deal more of it visible.

Scented Markers With Fruity Smells
by tolovemoon

Comment:
Wow, I remember these... do they really still make them?

Good choice, and I like the layout, but why is this so small?

onions on the grill
by coolhar

Comment:
Okay. When the voter's mouth starts watering upon seeing the picture, you have correctly done your job.

Freedom
by PERCOM

Comment:
Yes, and, uh... where's the scent?

Scent of Coriander
by BBBastet

Comment:
Oooo. I'm not a fan, personally, of coriander -- it always smells off to me -- but I very much like this shot (and is that a bit of cinnamon in the background?). Nice colours, lighting, focus.

by a creek in the Australian bush
by amwab

Comment:
Way too small. Also, since I can't tell what the plant is in part because of how small the shot is, I have no idea if it's really a particularly smelly one.

POOOOOOOT!
by dadas115

Comment:
Eh?

Okay, interesting picture of a frog (or is it a toad?) and all, but a) I never thought of amphibians as terribly smelly and b) I do NOT get your title.