topless or is it to much drink
by Thai

Comment:
Not a fan of the lighting; the specular highlights on the bottle. Two subjects as well... would have been better to do one or the other

Blender
by notesinstones

Comment:
Would have been great to see in the Stopped Motion challenge. Great colours against the black background

Topless Waterfall
by robzilla

Comment:
Nice long exposure "wispy" water effect. Could have pushed the deep tones harder in the water to really make it special and more dramatic.

Topless .... Flower Arrangement
by RamblinR

Comment:
The floor is a bit of a distration, a neural environment would have put the focus cleanly on the flowers. Nice colours and good idea

Though it would look better with people
by MistyMucky

Comment:
Nice idea, the shadow seems a bit noisy but might just be the texture of the surface.

Looking Skyward
by Bruce_the_Robert

Comment:
Pushing the boundaries of the challenge a little too hard perhaps.... wait, I've just clicked, topless, no roof... ok. Difficult lighting conditions to keep detail in the shadows so well done for that

Bottoms Up
by Photomouse

Comment:
The duck and main concept are this image are a bit lost against the surrounding environment. The percentage area taken up by the main subject is quite small. The duck is also a bit blurred. Nice idea but a more simplified shot just against water with perhaps a nice reflection would do better

Top or Bottom?
by Child of Light

Comment:
First thing that comes into my mind is the very strong/thick border. You also have some fairly major chromatic aberration going on; cyan at the back of the scene and magenta at the front, which is not so good and could easily have been corrected during post processing. The oranges are highly saturated and look as if they could be sharper

Fun in the Sun
by Cam

Comment:
Nice idea, the background takes away from the car though and has nothing to do with the subject or challenge. If the background was nicely blurred then I think it would score higher. The high scoring images tend to be very simple. I see the car against a completely neutral/plain background doing better. The viewpoint is taken from eye level, photographs with different viewpoints have more interest. If taken from lower down (wheel height for example) then I think it would be more dramatic

bird unwrapped his lollipop
by whiterook

Comment:
Just not in focus unfortunately, even if it was, I'm struggling to understand where the "topless" element is coming from.