Double Trouble
by JonoTucker

Comment:
Nice symmetry.

All Sweetness and Light
by RKT

Comment:
Very impressive in my opinion. Great colours and composition. I just can't put my finger on it, but something about this shot impresses me.

You Sneaky Bastard
by phoozt

Comment:
Wrong in so many ways :)

Aikido - Beach Dojo
by vlado

Comment:
Great action shot and I am really captured by the PP work done on it. The acid look has worked very well for this one.

insides...out
by laurie241

Comment:
Very clever. Cannot get tired of seeing images like these. They make me chuckle all the time.

American Beauty
by kevip6

Comment:
You were right Lydia. Didn't notice the knee. :)

Margerita Frozen
by Judi

Comment:
A great shot here Judi. Very serene looking image. If only the seas could be as calm as the waters in your shot.

Keith 1
by breadfan35

Comment:
Third image, third comment.

Nice image. Not sure if this might have been better just that bit further away in composition to include the top of the subjects head. You stated that you had done a little bit more processing than that allowable in basic. A couple of things (very picky) that could be cloned out of this shot is the bright hair in the beard (the one stray white hair on the shadowed side of his face, just below the bottom lip) and the fly-away hair just near the ear on the right side of his head (shadowed side).

I dont think that I could possibly find anything else in this shot. Sorry that it is not that in-depth,

Boring Afternoon II
by breadfan35

Comment:
Another comment after your request in the thread.

A similar shot to the first, and to be honest I think that this one might have been the better of the two for black and white due to the tigher crop. You have a darker background here, with very little on the light side in it, while your subject is fairly well lit and would convert relatively light in black and white. We generally see a single subject staring off in to the distance with room on the side that they are looking too. At first glance, I got the impression that she heard a commotion down the street and had turned that way to see what it was.

Even though I think that it would be the better of the two for black and white I still like the tones used in this shot.

Boring Afternoon
by breadfan35

Comment:
As requested in your thread, here are my thoughts on this shot.

I like the overall feel of the shot and the choice of black and white processing works well. There is something about the tree in the back right corner that keeps grabbing my attention away from your subject. Have you had a look at this with a tight crop around the girl only, as there is really not all that much in the background to support your main subject IMHO. A tighter crop would still leave you with the white house, hence leaving the viewer with the impression that the subject is sitting at the front of the house.

Nice work