The Shared Umbrella
by Melethia

Comment:
Nice one getting another ribbon for your collection and your first 7+ score. :D

Personally, I think that the black and white version is superior to the colour. The B&W gives it an old fashioned feel, I think, that works well with the scenery and clothing. :)

Pure White
by JuliBoc

Comment:
great shot! :)

A Shape From The Past
by BrianR

Comment:
Excellent well-deserved finish in my opinion :D

Double Spiral
by levyj413

Comment:
yee-haw. It's finally arrived!

Smooth droplet
by katOsu

Comment:
This shot is amazing and really sticks it to people who say you can't get a good shot with the Canon kit lens. :)

a classic punk rock opera...DPL!
by jonnienye

Comment:
creative use of straws. I like it.

Devotional Prayers Light
by yanko

Comment:
This is the most "album-cover" like shot I have seen so far, and a good quality shot also. 8

Night Time Stroll
by jaysonmc

Comment:
Okay, so you asked to concentrate on what is wrong. Fairly subjective really. I didn't vote but it would have been a 5 or 6. The lilac tone on the "eye" is good. However it's somewhat lacking in clarity and dynamics I think. The angle on the pods is a bit unflatering, for want of a better word. I wonder if a slower shutter would have made for a more interesting shot - though probably you would run the risk of people here calling it cliche. I'm also not sure if the big tree bottom right doesn't spoil the shot a bit. It's quite domineering and for me breaks the view of the other side of the river.

Trescott Street Pier
by bmartuch

Comment:
One of those odd shots where there is not too much to comment about. Surprised it didn't pick up a slightly higher score really. Would have been fine for the symmetry challenge I expect or the vanishing point. You could even do a re-shoot in a moody night sky.

They grow up so fast
by Melethia

Comment:
Ducks in a line is a great shot and would do well by itself I think. Does the original have any more space around it (to the left?)