Hot Wheels Set (CW)
by dtremain

Comment:
As you've effectively asked for comments (is it working?) here's mine.

I'm not voting because I'm in this challenge, but I think I would have given you a 5. I like your subject and you've photographed them well, but I think the composition lets it down. I feel you might have been better separating the cars more and having them facing diagonally across the image - that way you would have the large area of negative space at the top.

Hope this is the sort of comment you're looking for.

"Angel's Embrace" (CW)
by JokersSoul

Comment:
As you've effectively asked for comments (is it working?) here's mine.

I'm not voting because I'm in this challenge, but I think I would have given you a 5. It certainly fits the challenge. I like the composition and you've handled the exposure well. My major problem is that it doesn't look upright to me and I'm also not liking the wings being slightly out of focus.

Hope this is the sort of comment you're looking for.

Life is colourful - Express yourself (CW)
by Nadine_Vb

Comment:
As you've effectively asked for comments (is it working?) here's mine.

I'm not voting because I'm in this challenge, but I think I would have given you a 6. I like the "quality" of the image - i.e. it's in focus and exposed well, and more importantly I like the composition with the strong diagonals. As a "product" shot I'm not so sure about it. I feel that all the fragments make it look very messy so I don't think it sends the right message because of that.

Hope this is the sort of comment you're looking for.

Minimalist reflections
by hojop25

Comment:
Certainly an interesting take on the idea. To me it's just a little too far out of frame though

Duo
by Pug-H

Comment:
and here's to you Mrs Robotson

Variations
by Pug-H

Comment:
I could imaging making all these Claybots and displaying them as 3D Warhol tribute

Z15 Night Mission
by citymars

Comment:
It's got a rather ominous look to it

Under The Pier
by docmagic

Comment:
this is a bit too noisy for me

Eiffel Tower, the natural way!
by Silent-Shooter

Comment:
It's a bit too soft looking for me. I think it's the lack of contrast.

Down The Shopping Hole
by BenedictG

Comment:
A great composition, but strangely I find the colour off putting. How does it look in monochrome?