Winter Sunset
by Bear_Music

Comment:
Congrats on the ribbon Bear!!

BrOWn AND ARROW
by IsabellSchatz

Comment:
Love all the brown here! 9

Masquerade
by Pedro

Comment:
Wowowow. GREAT stuff here. Very nice tones and exposure.. FAVES

Headlines read : Overhead Power lines create visual pollution
by SDW

Comment:
Just stumbled across this. I really love the colors and lines!!

A Dirty Canvas
by kausikmpi

Comment:
Hi from the Critique Club!

At first glance, I kind-of like this image. It has a strong daguerreotype feeling to it.

Compositionally, its okay. The tower's slant is bothering me a little and messing up the flow of the photograph.

The exposure is obviously underexposed, but with the title I can see that is what you were going for (which doesn't make it a good or bad thing, it's what the artist is offering, if others "get it" or not it doesn't matter).

I think the voters were a little thrown by the unconventional display here. I think some of them were looking for "dirt" in the literal sense.

Overall, good job -- the feeling here was conveyed successfully (to me).

The Moon: Dirt or Cheese?
by TJinGuy

Comment:
Lol, please excuse the ignorance in my previous comment. I totally forgot the moon was dirt, therefore I didn't get it... But from your picture it looks more like cheese.

Last Christmas
by atlibj

Comment:
I think this photo is very underrated!! I really like it and it makes me think.. Very nice portrayal!

Migration Interupted
by ellamay

Comment:
Gorgeous, just gorgeous.. Masterfully done.

Life II Outtake
by escapetooz

Comment:
Really like this one too!!

The Moon: Dirt or Cheese?
by TJinGuy

Comment:
'Tis quite a big stretch to fit the challenge. Maybe a quick pass of sharpness might help this photo. Also, try and desat for a different look.