swiss reflection
by Andre_P69

Comment:
Why a 3? Mainly becaue I had to look so many times to figure out what it was I was looking at. I think shadows are great, but in this case, they detract from the picture.

Coffee pots of metal
by Antonino

Comment:
The greenish color cast and lack of a particular focus make this seem too much like a random jumble of items. Perhaps some reorganization of your props and a different camera angle?

One of a Kind
by k4ffy

Comment:
Well, it just doesn't say anything to me. It's out of focus and underexposed, which makes it not very interesting.

Hangover
by the great ubaldo

Comment:
Well, what can I say? It's a hanger. And it's out of focus

Sharp
by srdanz

Comment:
Cropping needs work. Too much non-related imagery detracts from the subject. Color looks oversaturated

Metal Boat
by hossam

Comment:
Poor photo quality (grid in the sky) and looks washed out.

Pizza Cutter & Friends
by ckempf

Comment:
It's definately metal, but it seems to much like a random jumble to really look like a composed shot.

big
by gtp1164

Comment:
It's not a bad photo, it just doesn't say anything to me. The top left portion (bridge and sky) are a bit of a distraction, too. Maybe a different angle?

Tracks
by drz01

Comment:
Why a 3? Doesn't really seem like a terribly composed photo. You can clearly see trash on the ground, and the framing doesn't tell me what I'm supposed to look at. Too many distracting elements plus the framing make this shot look too much like a random snapshot.

Metal, that has caused most pain in the History of humanity !
by kbhatia1967

Comment:
I'm not sure what to make of this photo. Overall, it's difficult to believe. The lighting makes the ketchup very obviously ketchup and not blood. The lights on the right side of the waterfront throw the photo out of context with the crucifixion timeframe, and Golgotha was nowhere near water, as far as I'm aware. Maybe if you cropped/edited out the lights, switched to b&w, and gave it some dark shadows, it might be a more believable photo. I know this probably sounds overly critical, but I don't see the point in marking you with a low score but not saying why.