A tree on a Harley
by dimitrii

Comment:
This is most odd. I think seeing the whole vehicle would have been a lot better because as it stands, it looks a little too much like ordinary mirrors, only B&W.

Reach for the Stars
by onthegomama

Comment:
This is just so weirdâ€Â¦ Is that a reflection of the stars? I really like the surrealistic nature of the shot; it works really well. But, I can't decide how this has been done, the reflection looks more like a shadow, or the figure in the shots transparent; if it was a reflection of the sky, I wouldn't be able to see the through the person. Ohhhh, this is so wacky. I am going to have to ask you how you did this after the challengeâ€Â¦ Whatever you've done here, I'm impressedâ€Â¦ (10)

Rose Water
by focus

Comment:
Great image. I love the mystic feel of the shot – makes the water look a little crystal ball like. The rose is ghostly, and the bright line looks almost like an intersecting electrical energy force. Colours look great as well. Only way I think this could be improved is to perhaps crop in a bit closer so that the surrounding area doesn't draw the eye away. The DOF works well, this helps with the composition; perhaps – I'm nit picking now – cropping just a tiny fraction to left might have helped as well. (7) Good luck.

splash
by willem

Comment:
I love the colour in the shot, I love how it looks and I think it's a great shotâ€Â¦ (10) I tried so hard to achieve this and failed; please, how'd you do it?

Mates for life
by sns

Comment:
Classic idea. Classic shot with only one tiny flaw – as far as I am concerned anyway. The diagonal lines that look as though they are growing out of the ducks kill the balance within the shot; I would suggest an un-tiled floor. Try photoshopping them out and you'll see what I mean. Sorry to be negative – great idea and a great shot thoughâ€Â¦ (8)

Black and Grey
by AndyLeeG4

Comment:
For me, this would have been superb but for a small – but hugely invasive – point; the diagonal wooden strut. This just drags the eye away from what is a really good idea. The shot itself, if you mask out the wooden bit, is first class; great colour, superb composition and terrific use of DOF. The other effect of the diagonal in this shot, is to remove the mood balance - rather like playing loud rock music at a chess clubâ€Â¦ Sorry to be so negative, but it's a really good shot that could have been superbâ€Â¦ (7)

windows
by dean

Comment:
This is superb. I really love the shot. Composition is absolutely first class, lighting is outstanding and the challenge element is met with aplomb. I can't fault the shot – the colours and symmetry work faultlessly and bring out the best in both the foreground and the reflection elementâ€Â¦ Classic shootingâ€Â¦ (10)

Choice
by Nocturno

Comment:
Ohhhh, great shotâ€Â¦ I've been playing spot the difference for the last twenty minutes. I can't fault the composition, but I can fault it in one area. The focus is slightly off. But, that doesn't mean the shot isn't first classâ€Â¦ Any shot that can hold the attention for twenty minutes has to get a good scoreâ€Â¦ Great idea, worth ten for the idea alone, I really like the ' at first glance it's a blooming mirror' effectâ€Â¦ Then you start to spot the subtle changes made between the two subjectsâ€Â¦ Keep this up, it's inventive shots like this that make DPC a special place. (10+++)

Ghost in the Machine
by jmsetzler

Comment:
Great idea, superbly doneâ€Â¦ Just the right level of lighting to give the shot a really spooky appearance. The only improvement I could possibly suggest here relates to the word Nikon. Because it also reflects the background, it does detract from the within notion - but I haven't a clue as to how you could have prevented that. Aside from the really trivial point, it's a great shotâ€Â¦ (9)

The Truth Is Out There
by Manic

Comment:
Great idea and not a bad shot considering the degradation the image must have suffered to get it. No lake – great, gets another point :o) I like a lot of things here, but – and I know how hard it would be to improve it – it does lack a bit of sharpnessâ€Â¦ (8) First class ideaâ€Â¦