Fire Island Light House
by TLL061

Comment:
I think this will suffer because of the link to the challenge. I know it said any interpretation of a light, but I think this will get marked down because it is a picture of a big light and not a subtle or novel interpretation.

As for the photo itself, I would like to see it rotated a fraction so the light is vertical and the horizon level. The background and foreground are both a little dull and the whole thing looks a bit lifeless to me.

I would have like to have seen this taken at dusk on a day with a beautiful sky and the lighthouse operating. I think that would have scored much higher.

Gerbera in a WInter Light
by admart01

Comment:
You've certainly captured a wonderful slice of light there, beautiful composition.

Love the simplicity. Gets an 8 from me.

Lightest
by dan_pendleton

Comment:
Very, very clever. I wish the reflections from the flash and umbrellas (?) weren't quite so visible but I suppose that is unavoidable.

Great take on the challenge and gets an 8 from me.

Red, Red, Wine
by Tranquil

Comment:
Beautifully lit and I love the detail on the surface of the liquid, very nice touch. Gets an 8 from me.

Curves and Shadows
by unohuu

Comment:
Love the simplicity. Great take on the challenge. I just don't like thw way it curves at the bottom left, I think it would be better with a slightly tighter crop to get rid of that.

Pink Pong
by Falc

Comment:
Very nicely arranged and lit. Just goes to show what you can achieve with some ping pong balls, a lengrh of ribbon and a good imagination (along with some photog skills of course).

The only thing I don't like is that distraction in the bottom right. I don't understand why you didn\t clone that out. Gets my 8, would be a 9 without that/

Lite
by caba

Comment:
Love what you've achieved here. That really is 'painting with light'. 9

Color of Light
by Telehubbie

Comment:
Not sure about the blue border.

A "light" Champagne
by wetland

Comment:
Love the colours and the lighting here.

DARK SKY, BRIGHT LIGHT
by hauntingimagez

Comment:
This will suffer due to the small size and the artefacts on the light. Have a look through the forum for topics on resampling and resizing in your software.

The image itself doesn't really have any interest for me. The sky is not spectacular and the light is just an average light.