November
by bruski

Comment:
Beautiful scene. The first thing I noticed, (when looking for things that could be improved), is the deep black shadows under the trees, nothing wrong with black shadows but, because there's not a lot happening over to the right of the shot, just some nice sky and some distant background, the trees and the deep shadows make the shot a bit un balanced, in my opinion. If possible I would have moved to the right some way and tried to keep the reflection and rocks in the foreground, bringing the mountain more central to try to balance things up a bit more. Well done though for some stunning scenery, a six from me.

November - First Snow
by Gauti

Comment:
An unusual subject, given interest by the snow lying on it. The buildings in background are a bit distracting, the mountain is ok but the light is a bit flat from this angle. I don't know what was around to the left but it seems that the warm light is being reflected from the other side of the art work and that would have produced a better shot. As I said I don't know what was in the background but that's where the light is. Well done though, a six from me.

September
by Bud

Comment:
Beautiful, no doubt. I think I would have cropped just a little more from the bottom. The reflection is good but the sky is where its at and the horizon is almost across the middle. Well exposed under tricky lighting conditions, well done, a six from me.

August
by Zoomdak

Comment:
I have a thing about horizons, look at other comments I've made and you'll see. It may be an illusion but, the horizon seems to dip to the right to me? Apart from that the colours are great and are wonderfully reflected in the pool. The grasses are nicely silhouetted, there's some sky detail but I can't help feeling there should be something on the right to balance it a bit? Very nice shot all the same, a six from me.

November
by floyd

Comment:
Great colours, nicely framed, wonderful lighting. I normally shy away from having people in my shots but in this case I think a figure in a bright red coat walking away, about two thirds of the way down the line of trees would have made this even better, in my opinion. Well done a six from me.

Doggie Days - August - Dachshund
by smokeditor

Comment:
Perfect pose, a well trained dog. Good focussing, I can almose see your reflection in the eyes. Wonderful lighting, lovely colour, a six from me.

October
by charmayne

Comment:
Beautiful colours, both the trees and the sky. Plus a reflection as well. Only one thing and that is that its very lefty, I mean the eye is lead out to the right by the lake and the reeds and then...there's nothing out there to look at. Perhaps a different viewpoint further along to the right may have been better? (If possible?) Well done anyway and a six from me.

Novembers free study of collores
by Dufus

Comment:
Wonderful image. All those streams and waterfalls lead the eye up to the sumit, just visible through the mist and the colours are superb. If anything it seems a bit over sharpened. Well done, a six from me.

November
by vtruan

Comment:
A very nice view, quite well composed. The tree is well placed against the mountains and the lake. The picnic table on the rise is a bit small a larger object like a building would have been better, (I know there's nothing you could do about that). It seems a bit hazy and it looks as though you've tried to remedy that by sharpening and it may be overdone slightly. If so, a polerising filter may help. Very well done, a six from me.

November Train
by frumoaznicul

Comment:
A nice idea,s elective de-sat? The leaves have also lost their colour and therefore their punch which leaves the whole thing looking a bit flat. A change of veiwpoint would improve the shot, in my opinion. Tighter in to loose the footpath, lower down to emphasize the train and slightly left to loose some of the distrcting background. When composing a shot like this where you have plenty of time, use it and have a good look around the veiwfinder and make sure only the things you want in the shot can be seen. Well done though, a six from me.