Contemplation
by dwterry

Comment:
Fantastic portrait. Composition, expression, lighting, editing...you name it, all right on point. I keep looking for something wrong and can't find anything...aka 10.

whakatopa
by rinac

Comment:
nice capture but the sky has a bit too much cyan. 7

All Alone
by mpeters

Comment:
Great job, would love to see the original of this. 8

Friday Harbor Lighthouse
by jblaylockrayner

Comment:
I like the way you perfectly framed the lighthouse but feel this would be much more powerful cropped into a square. You could litterally lose the entire top half of the frame and this would greatly improve the photo. The true subject is the harbor and lighthouse so why bother including so much of the tree you're using to frame the subject. 6

Old-and-New-Windmill-2325.jpg
by Monique64

Comment:
Overall a decent image. While this may not even be possible, I would rather see the new windmill in the foreground because the pattern it creates in the sky is far more interesting than the single tail on the old one. The tones are nice, lots of texture. I would consider burning in the trees way off in the distance, they just seem too artificially bright. The composition would benefit from being slightly lower to really seperate the far windmill instead of having it split by the horizon. I could be wrong but it looks like you did some dodging up on the windmill tail in the sky and created a little halo. I like the idea of dodging that dark spot but I'd be careful to not let it effect any of the surroundings. Hope this helps, I try to leave real comments rather than 'nice pic'. Have a good day.

The Gothic Chain
by librodo

Comment:
I'd say you're exactly right about no one recognizing you. A cool shot though for sure. I gave it a 7

Free
by daboardergirl

Comment:
I'm suprised this didn't score higher, very cool shot.

Contained
by littlegett

Comment:
I thought this should have scored much higher, I gave it a nine. Good stuff though and congrats on a cool shot.

150 lbs
by SaraR

Comment:
I think i would rather see this focused on her reflection than on her back.

khis
by hidayat_hevard

Comment:
Take some time to read the tutorial on how to prepare images for dpchallenge so you have them at maximum size. Next time try to take a picture that is somewhat relevant to the challenge. A sitting squirrel doesn't say fitness to me in any way. Better luck next time