La Mer
by Giles

Comment:
Great capture! Lovely colors and nice soft feeling in the water and the sky. I think I would prefer a little less rocks in the photo and more water, but not sure how I would had solved this if this was my image. Perhaps a different crop or maybe taking the picture from a different angle? Then again I could be completely wrong on the rock/sea ratio :) (BTW, do you need to clean your lens or sensor? I rubbed my screen for ages before I realized it was the image! Haha...) Good luck in the challenge :)

Sirmione
by Sisto

Comment:
I can't really put my finger on what (in my eyes) does not look quite right in this image. It's a 7 from me. Maybe it is the soft calm feel of the horizon against the more saturated, clear houses? I'm not sure. Still, I like the angle and the city works well as a leading line towards the horizon. Best of luck in the challenge.

Longhorns
by P-A-U-L

Comment:
They look a bit evil! Are they? The big one even has some flames in his right eye ;p But seriously, nice capture! Best of luck in the challenge :)

The Last of the Super Moons
by Len Scap

Comment:
Wonderful! Perfect silhouette of the tree line! Details in the moon looks great! Best of luck in the challenge :)

Dimension
by Cuttooth

Comment:
Super nice and smooth water. Just enough detail in the forground. For me the color balance is great. Very harmonious! The vignetting/burning in the left corners is perhaps a tiny tiny bit too dark, but that is only a minor issue for me. The rest is great! Good luck in the challenge :)

Surfing
by mqnaufal

Comment:
I like it! The "surfer" makes it a bit different the sunset/sunrise images I usually see. I wonder if the rocks could benefit from being even darker, because the guy is almost a silhouette (at least on my screen), or vice versa. Or maybe I'm completely wrong :) Still, its a nice image. I gave it an 8. Good luck in the challenge! :)

Hunting Egret
by Nobody

Comment:
Beautiful bird and great capture! Best of luck in the challenge!

Twilight's Mountain Glow
by marbro

Comment:
Love it! Like it even better now on second look. Bumping up to a 9. The colors are just beautiful and cudos for capturing the reflection in the water. Makes the image extra interesting. I'm n my view you have just enough forground to balance the gorgeous montains and tree line. Good luck in the challenge :)

The Lone Wanderer
by HalldorIngi

Comment:
I think this a wonderful image. It is especially interesting because it is almost like it is night and day at the same time. For me however the bottom left, which is the least interesting part, is taking a little too much attention. The rest is great though :) Must have been a exciting event! I'm jealous. Despite being Norwegian I have never seen the northern lights.

Church at Bonanza Creek Ranch
by franktheyank

Comment:
I really like this one. Perfect sharp, DOF and perspective. Is the church perhaps a tiny bit too light on the wall facing the viewer? Not sure! Regardless, great image! Best of luck in the challenge :)