Sweets For My Sweet
by idnic

Comment:
I voted this one middle of the road during the challenge. A couple of reasons.

First, I didn't really say romance to me. Of all the reasons I had, that one plyed into my voting the least, because I realize how subjective that is.

Second, there are sharpening artifacts and jaggies on the edge of your plate and heart. This is something that can be avoided, and for whatever reason drives me bonkers.

Next, the color cast. The whites in this image seem to have a tinge of pink in them. I assume it's reflection from the heart. It give the image a warmer feel, but your white aren't white...

Finally, there's what I'm going to assume is senosr dust dotted over the image... I know it's basic editing, but you may want to physically clean that...

Hope this helps! =] Trey

All alone with my cold broken heart
by cbonsall

Comment:
...and your coding book?

Inside the broken house
by Ian-Andrew

Comment:
The colors feel a bit muddled. I like the concept.

The Corrosive Touch of Time
by DrAchoo

Comment:
You've got some pretty severe haloing going on here... It's a really nice shot though

Pillar Point
by Sheila

Comment:
Tilted horizon, and the colors seem flat.

My Diet
by cislander

Comment:
Yum! Why didn't you use the full 640x640?

No Exit
by ericwoo

Comment:
Leaning a bit to the left, and the crop is a little tight, other wise, very cool!

Broken Down with Age !!
by mightythor

Comment:
Looks really washed out. I like the composition, though!

No Vacancy
by Cam

Comment:
Way oversharpened. There are jaggies on all the window lines as well as compression artifacts around the edges of the building. It's a shame, b/c I really like this shot.

forgotten
by tommyd65

Comment:
This is a cool shoot. A couple of things I'd change, however. First, the crop on the right side is too tight. I think this image would benefit greatly from being able to see some brick on the right of the sill. Second, the perspective. I'm not sure if it was possible, but if you could have gotten your camera a little higheryou wouldn't have the problem of both sides of the window tilting in as you go higher.