bottles
by phatmatt11

Comment by carisakD70:
Original

bottles
by phatmatt11

Comment by nsmith:
I like your idea but I think the objects in the backgroup detract from it.

bottles
by phatmatt11

Comment by cosmic:
The concept of this is great, but you should have put them on a solid surface and have a solid background... or crop it.

bottles
by phatmatt11

Comment by rex:
This would be a lot better if it were a solid color background. I believe the reflections can work to your advantage in this kind of shot.

bottles
by phatmatt11

Comment by sirena:
you should have beeen more carefull with choosing the backround...

bottles
by phatmatt11

Comment by vadvirag:
The idea is great! The background is too busy and therefore distracting. I also feel WB problems here. I would show more of the text on the old bottle and I miss the top of the bottles very much. This subject cries for a portrait crop. I think noone needed these bottles anymore, in your shoes I would have taken them home to make a nice composition. I would have filled them with Coke as well, but at least the new one. Use diffused light for glass, because reflections can be very distracting and cause overexposed areas sometimes.

bottles
by phatmatt11

Comment by Xilebo:
Idea is good but the colors of the background are distracting and unattractive, wish you had just placed the bottles on a white tablecloth, one lying down, one standing for example....

bottles
by phatmatt11

Comment by Pug-H:
Background is way too distracting; you could have done much better with this subject (inclding filling the bottles, perhaps).

bottles
by phatmatt11

Comment by messerschmitt:
i would have appreciated this thought much more if u used a recycableCocaCola bottle instead to emphasize the juxtapostion

bottles
by phatmatt11

Comment by ClickNSee:
When I thought about this challenge, I thought of about 20 different ideas, and each and everyone of them have been represented here. This, however, is one I did not think of. I like this. Good going. 8