Rocky water
by sassygtr

Comment by marbo:
Could be a bit more interesting.

Rocky water
by sassygtr

Comment by faidoi:
Good contrast of the green grass, the rocks , and the muddy water. The stone in the water gives it some added interest.

Rocky water
by sassygtr

Comment by nborton:
if you wanted the stone in the water to be the subject i would have gotten much closer to it. getting in closer creates pictures that don't look like everyday sights, which in turn creates a more interesting photo.

Rocky water
by sassygtr

Comment by TooCool:
Too small and too soft in the foreground.
TC

Rocky water
by sassygtr

Comment by tfaust:
This would be better somewhat larger, you might also benefit from some contrast adjustment to let in a little more color with the grass. Otherwise, there isn't a lot of interest in this shot...

Rocky water
by sassygtr

Comment by scrum8:
I might have tried for closer crop. The foreground and background seem to be in competition for my attention.

Rocky water
by sassygtr

Comment by magnetic9999:
sorry, too small .....

Simply Checking Each Other Out
by sassygtr

Comment by ahaze:
Technical: Most all images submitted fit the challenge, but this one isn't strong for me. Exposure composition focus lighting all good.

Personal: This feels like a "right place right time" photo- it's very cute, but for me it only very loosely fits the challenge. I'd also prefer to see it at the full 640 pixels allowed!

My vote:4

Rocky water
by sassygtr

Comment by Dave Gordon:
This has the makings of a really nice shot, but it needs more saturation in the colors and possible a different angle. The rock isn't really enough to create a focal point.

Simply Checking Each Other Out
by sassygtr

Comment by oldgit:
Lacking in contrast/detail around cat. Also cat shaddow is a little distracting. Not bad otherwise