Petal Grace
by shedonist

Comment by justine:
Nice maco, good color.

Petal Grace
by shedonist

Comment by Shiiizzzam:
Superb photo !

a resolution waiting to be broken
by shedonist

Comment by jimmsp:
Critique Club Critique
(1) COMPOSITION (CONTENT) - The idea of the scale and weight loss is clearly a New Year�s challenge for many people. However, this is a photo with everything �centered� (feet & scale). This tends to make it uninteresting. I don�t think B&W helps.
(2) BACKGROUND � OK. The floor does not distract from the photo.
(3) CAMERA WORK ,TECHNICAL � Good. I�m not sure that B&W is the best format for this. There is really not a lot of contrast; certainly no mood in evidence.
(4) DIGITAL PROCESSING ,TECHNICAL � Nothing to suggest. Everything looks fine.
(5) MY OPINION ON THE PHOTO � A good symbolic photo, but doesn�t draw me in. I can�t say that it gives me a lot more than a �good shot� feeling. On the other hand, I don�t have any great suggestions as to how to modify it. I don�t think color would change my opinion a lot. Maybe if you added a �Goal = 175� paste on sign.

a resolution waiting to be broken
by shedonist

Comment by jimmsp:
"duplicate"

Message edited by author 2003-01-13 20:59:28.

a resolution waiting to be broken
by shedonist

Comment by joanns:
Here's my dilema. I really want to see the scale centered but to do that, you would have to crop your toes. Maybe not such close cropping would make the uncentered scale less noticable. Anyway, aside from my balance problem, and the slight out of focus right foot, I like it .

a resolution waiting to be broken
by shedonist

Comment by KarenB:
great image.. don't we just know this routine! LOL... means alot, and says alot.

a resolution waiting to be broken
by shedonist

Comment by KimInNB:
Here's a better idea - make a resolution to GAIN WEIGHT - then if you do break it you're not upset!!

a resolution waiting to be broken
by shedonist

Comment by PTLParsons:
A very good photo. And it will be broken! This is really. Hope you don't get beat up about "feet". I like this shot. I'd give it an 8. PTL

a resolution waiting to be broken
by shedonist

Comment by Davenit:
Nicely captured B+W. Excellent stuff...

Dave

a resolution waiting to be broken
by shedonist

Comment by joshua:
another hobbit trying to lose weight, what's up with that