Old School
by TeeCeeJay

Comment:
I like the concept of this image, but the out of focus (or soft focus) is distracting to me in a composition that I think would look better in focus. Possible a DOF issue, as it seems that the focus point is in front of the camera lends by a couple of inches. I think this would have been more effective if the front of the lens where the focus point.

Days Gone By
by got2bgutsy

Comment:
I like this image, but the houses in the background take away from the illusion of "Days Gone By". A close crop would fix the one on the right, bu the ones on the left are problematic.

Tai Chi Sword Play
by JuliBoc

Comment:
I like this image (the colors, saturation), but the blown out background is very distracting

Tools of the Trade
by fantomfoto

Comment:
Great image...just wondering why spot color? To me, I think the syringe/pills bring this old time flavor image into the present just fine. A solid 8.

Peach Bouquet
by idnic

Comment:
This is a gorgeous image, but I fear that many will see the slight colors still in the image (ie, the greens in the bouquet) and not consider it a true "sepia" image even though it has a light sepia cast.

A Rose is a Rose is a Rose is a Rose
by tennernie

Comment:
I really like this image, and at first I scored it very low because it initially came across to me as a gray scale image, not sepia. However, after looking at all the images on three different systems, I do see the sepia, however lightly applied. I fear that your image may not fare well if others feel it is B/W or gray scale, rather than sepia.

v o g u e
by kundimansabuwan

Comment:
I like this image. I did look at it on three different systems and while it may have a slight sepia tint, it could just as easily be desaturated. Not a big issue in any other challenge, but I guess in a sepia challenge, it is to me.

Seems Like Only Yesterday
by togtog

Comment:
Not sure if the grain is intentional (I assume it is), but I found the lighting to be flat, and the composition awkward. I would have liked this much more with some shadows/depth to it.

Architectual Landscape
by shutterbug8

Comment:
I like this photo, however, the inclusion of the blue tones in the sky/glass does not mesh with my understanding of a sepia image.

A Rose for Grandma
by 777STAN

Comment:
IMO, DNMC. Very nice flower image, but in B/W.