drop
by posthumous

Comment:
I gave you a six. Should have been a seven or eight, but no way should this be 2nd from last. It makes no sense. I am depressed for you.

Autumn Delight
by skewsme

Comment:
Woohoo! Awesome placement on the lovely image

H Bomb
by posthumous

Comment:
I don't know. This is definitely better than mine. You shouldn't be so far down for this.

getting married
by lobrin

Comment:
My favorite in the challenge. Something about the candidness works here. It looks like they are having such a great time on their day. Good toning and good composition. Great control of light. Fun stuff. A pleasure to view.

Wind and Clouds
by Alex_Petrini

Comment:
I missed the wind? Where is it? The lake looks pretty still to me?

As for the landscape itself. It has a good mirrored reflection, good detail in the foreground and the colors are nice and warm. It is a very scenic shot, you should be happy with the result. Wish I could be there.

Frozen Breeze
by Pascal

Comment:
Frozen breeze? Is that like non-flowing river?

I do see little tufts up there. But is that wind or evaporation? I can't tell. The viewer shouldn't have to guess.

As for the shot itself. I really enjoy the three tones you have here: blue, white, and brown. Nice, good detail in the snow. You can briefly see that trail/road line going across, very neat. Good forward-presence landscape.

High as a kite
by P-A-U-L

Comment:
One of the best shots of the group. You captured the essence of win here, but you also captured the eye of the viewer. I might have gone with a different toning myself, but nothing wrong with the way it is. I like how the trees and fence round on the compositional elements. Hope it does well for you.

Jordyn
by kitkatklok

Comment:
Honestly due to the processing I can't tell if this is Wind or if this is just soft edges. You took the detail out of the hair, so it doesn't mean much to the challenge.

As for the photo itself. I do like the processing. I think the eye contact with the viewer is spot on. I also like the purple with the green. This all makes for a very 'magical' photo. I think you did good work here.

Black Breeze
by Tiberius

Comment:
You know, you have a good image here.
Good dark and white balance.
Good shapes.
It keeps the viewer engaged.
The slight tilt... not too sure, but I will go with it.

Wind, prominent. So it is a winner here.

W"i"ndy
by zaflabout

Comment:
There are about four images that should place.
This is one of them.
Good back ground
Good light.
Good wind.

Just wish there was more engagement with the subject and the viewer...
It's a bit too casual for me.

However, given the field of entries this is miles above most. 9.
Good luck.