BW Beach
by rook

Comment:
Nice image, but I don't like the heavy border !

Quality Time
by rbenny

Comment:
A flash would helped to fill in the missing light and to create a nice effect but still keep it moody if that was what you were trying to achieve this image .

Isthmus in the City
by tmhalling

Comment:
Nice shot - I love the colors and general feel of this image! I have given you the following ratings...

Meeting the Challenge 0-1-2 = 2
Overall look, feel and composition 0-1-2 = 2
Creativity 0-1-2 = 2
Quality and execution 0-1-2 = 2
WOW effect and first impression 0-1-2 = 2

Final : 10

Well done !!

Redemption
by macrothing

Comment:
Wonderful DOF and great image !! Here is my rating :

Meeting the Challenge 0-1-2 = 2
Overall look, feel and composition 0-1-2 = 2
Creativity 0-1-2 = 2
Quality and execution 0-1-2 = 2
WOW effect and first impression 0-1-2 = 1

Final : 9

Low Tide
by charliebaker

Comment:
Great image ! The line between sky and sea is a little bit to high for me , but overall it's a beautiful composition.

My ratings are:

Meeting the Challenge 0-1-2 = 2
Overall look, feel and composition 0-1-2 = 1
Creativity 0-1-2 = 1
Quality and execution 0-1-2 = 2
WOW effect and first impression 0-1-2 = 2

Final : 8

Chillin'
by idnic

Comment:
Nice shot and I like the feel to it ... I have given you the following ratings for this picture

Meeting the Challenge 0-1-2 = 2
Overall look, feel and composition 0-1-2 = 1
Creativity 0-1-2 = 1
Quality and execution 0-1-2 = 2
WOW effect and first impression 0-1-2 = 1

Final : 7

To nowhere
by Odie

Comment:
Great shot and I like the idea .... However Its just a little overexposed on the top left side (no big deal), but I would have given it a higher rating if you would have managed to focus more onto the center of the picture allowing the inspectors eyes to wonder from there and to explore the rest. This could have been achieved by bringing down the line between water and beach, and perhaps by changing ever so slightly the angle, moving the camera closer to the railings. I think the end of the railings and the beginning of the water should be in the center. I rated it a 7