Self.atop.AC via.Digital.Camera Circa.2006.August.08
by otisXmike

Comment:
looks great ... I have given you the following ratings

Meeting the Challenge 0-1-2 = 2
Overall look, feel and composition 0-1-2 = 2
Creativity 0-1-2 = 2
Quality and execution 0-1-2 = 2
WOW effect and first impression 0-1-2 = 1

Final : 9

I will Survive
by tuffy

Comment:
Stunning picture ... I have given you the following ratings

Meeting the Challenge 0-1-2 = 2
Overall look, feel and composition 0-1-2 = 2
Creativity 0-1-2 = 1
Quality and execution 0-1-2 = 2
WOW effect and first impression 0-1-2 = 1

Final : 8

Butterfly Flowers
by remarsh

Comment:
Wonderful shot ... I have given you the following ratings

Meeting the Challenge 0-1-2 = 2
Overall look, feel and composition 0-1-2 = 2
Creativity 0-1-2 = 1
Quality and execution 0-1-2 = 1
WOW effect and first impression 0-1-2 = 1

Final : 7

Interior
by messerschmitt

Comment:
fabulous shot, I love it !!

Royal marriage in the chessboard
by greslizzz

Comment:
One of the few pictures in this challenge that i actually like ! Well done!!

The Box
by bood

Comment:
Great picture ! If I am right you are going to get a ribbon with that one .. Congratulation!!

Deconstruction
by mist

Comment:
I like your Deconstruction piece .... you should make a series out of it and offer it for viewing

Hanging at the Museum
by Jenga

Comment:
nice image , been there and taken a similar one !! I know it is hard to get the W/B right , but that's what this image would benefit from.

Beach Front Property In Phoenix Arizona
by JSAYB

Comment:
This picture seems to be a little bit unbalanced and by rotating the image slightly clockwise could give it a better feel. Its all about balance unless you shoot a perspective photo.

Meeting the Challenge 0-1-2 = 1 doesn't have the beach feeling that I was looking for
Overall look, feel and composition 0-1-2 = 1
Creativity 0-1-2 = 1 seems just like to photo to me with no great effort on the compositing
Quality and execution 0-1-2 = 1 the colors could be stronger and feels a bit bland
WOW effect and first impression 0-1-2 = 0 It doesn't quite pop out enough to make me excited

Final : 4

Defending Legends
by anthonyczaja

Comment:
Lovely picture and I can just see it in a holiday brochure advertising for a Hawaiian trip...

Meeting the Challenge 0-1-2 = 2
Overall look, feel and composition 0-1-2 = 2
Creativity 0-1-2 = 1
Quality and execution 0-1-2 = 2
WOW effect and first impression 0-1-2 = 1

Final : 8