Night Time Tag
by liberty

Comment:
Original concept for this challenge, good work!

The Open Sky
by gaurav

Comment:
I'm sure you've got one or two comments already but I had to score this low because I can't tell what it is. Focus is way off, composition is off balance, theres way too much noise in the photo. In future, try isolating your subject and if your incorporating additional items into the shot (such as the fluff in the bottom right corner) make sure they add something to the picture. Good luck.

Cottongrass
by Gauti

Comment:
Great landscape picture, excellent dark feeling and moody atmosphere.

Just Above The Water
by jrjr

Comment:
Very serene looking, gives a good feeling of peace. Nice work.

Beautiful New Zealand
by keriboi

Comment:
I'm a bit unsure of this, I think the bottom 1/3rd looks too cluttered and doesn't contrast well with the empty sky. If the sky had been more dramatic (thunderstorm, dark clouds etc) I think it would have worked better for me.

David & Goliath
by littlebigman

Comment:
I think a closer crop would have beneffited this photo, this might have knocked the smaller boat out of the exact third area, but the ROT is only a guideline as long as you get it aproximately near the thirds mark it will work. I do like the comparision of the two boats though, well done.

Jump for Joy
by MarcelLainez

Comment:
This is an excellent image which for me is let down slightly by the blurring of the child. I know this is meant to show motion, but a photographer once said to me if your trying to achieve an effect in an image, make sure it doesn't look accidental. If you wanted blurred movement it should be more blurred, if you wanted to freeze the action it should be sharper. Please accept this as constructive criticism as I really do like this one :)

Cotton Blue
by bairas

Comment:
Excellent colours in this, great composition too, well done.

Light
by macrothing

Comment:
Great image, my only reservation is that the flowers seem to be lost in the background and don't stand out enough for my liking. Well done though!

Andrew
by Shea927

Comment:
I'm sure this has already been commented on but the image is under exposed, you've lost detail in the blacks and retained detail in the whites in the background. Add a couple of stops of exposure next time, as this is a nice image which gives a real connection to the model and a good feeling of contemplation.